I wouldn't trust the meta too much. Apparently there was some shady business going on with that game, a memo was sent to critics asking them to play it on the lowest difficulty setting, and they were also given tips and guides to help them get through the game, just to keep the scores higher. Some of my favorite Youtubers attempted to record playthroughs of it last night, apparently the game is pretty bad, it's not very scary, it's just foreboding, and by the time you actually reach the scary bits you're already so frustrated with some shoddy gameplay mechanics that you don't even notice it. My favorite Youtuber said it's the worst game he's played since Ride To Hell: Retribution, and that game has been labeled one of the worst video games ever made.

If you want a scary game on Xbox One, Alien: Isolation and Outlast seem like much better choices right now.