By using this site, you agree to our Privacy Policy and our Terms of Use. Close

Forums - Sony Discussion - Sony exclusives that went multiplat have largely failed

 

Is this truth>?

yes 168 42.21%
 
maybe 58 14.57%
 
no 172 43.22%
 
Total:398
Wright on 04 April 2013
enditall727 said:


They would've sold if they were QUALITY

 

and Wipeout gets a pass because NOTHING really sold on Vita at the time. It probably would've did good if it released when Vita hit$ 199 worldwide


^ So you're implying that Starhawk is not a quality game? D: Because it sold really, really bad, and if we follow this path of logic...



Around the Network
NiKKoM on 04 April 2013
Wright said:
enditall727 said:


They would've sold if they were QUALITY

 

and Wipeout gets a pass because NOTHING really sold on Vita at the time. It probably would've did good if it released when Vita hit$ 199 worldwide


^ So you're implying that Starhawk is not a quality game? D: Because it sold really, really bad, and if we follow this path of logic...

then he's also saying Sly Cooper 4 isn't quality... D:



 

Face the future.. Gamecenter ID: nikkom_nl (oh no he didn't!!) 

kain_kusanagi on 04 April 2013
enditall727 said:


you have to remember that Square cut a MAJOR load of content from the ps3 version of FF13 to fit on 3 360 discs

 

FF13 would've been a better overall game

we will never know what FF13 was REALLY supposed to be like

 

but what's done is done

Now it wasn't. That is a myth. FF13 was almost certainly finished and ready to go when at the last minute it was delayed to be ported to 360. It would have been the exact same game had it been a PS3 exclusive. Stuff gets cut from all games during development for many reasons. Everything that was cut from FF13 was most probably cut before it was ported, which is normal for game development. There is no evidence to suggest that the game was changed in any way due to the limited disc space of the 360. The 360 version was compressed and put on multiple discs and that's the only difference.



Wright on 04 April 2013
NiKKoM said:
Wright said:
enditall727 said:


They would've sold if they were QUALITY

 

and Wipeout gets a pass because NOTHING really sold on Vita at the time. It probably would've did good if it released when Vita hit$ 199 worldwide


^ So you're implying that Starhawk is not a quality game? D: Because it sold really, really bad, and if we follow this path of logic...

then he's also saying Sly Cooper 4 isn't quality... D:


He's also telling us that Tokio Jungle isn't a quality title, despite the rough technical department D:



oniyide on 04 April 2013
enditall727 said:
oniyide said:
This is true, if one wants to ignore the multiple factors going into these games. install base has already been mentioned and genre has been mentioned.

Tekken 6 is seen as worst than 5 which is probably why it didnt do as well. (Scenario mode? the hell was that?) if it was exclusive it would have sold the same, because those who bought it on xbox would have bought it on PS3 and would have the same numbers. You could say the same for most these games

Crash sucked after ND stop developing it, that simple. People arent stupid they noticed the dip in quality.

KH you are comparing a main entry to what are essentially handheld spinoffs. it is unfair and a flawed comparison. not to mention there was a KH game released BEFORE KH2 came out on a non Sony system, so its more of an issue with people not wanting to play these games on handhelds

Persona4 you know this is wrong but youre going with it anyway. Nice, fighters are not that popular unless its Smash, SF, or MK.

katamari maybe

FF lets ignore how divisive ff13 was. IMHO it would have done worst, because people were not going to buy PS3s for what is seen as a mediocore game at best

MGS why compare main entries to spinoffs? makes no sense. of course people are not going to buy it, as an MGS fan. Im not getting it because for all intents purposes its not a MGS game. Its a hacknslash with MG paint on it.

GTA maybe

DMC the quality of the latter doesnt come close to DMC3. not even a contest.

TR one it was never really exclusive. so argument is already flawed. the first was released on PC and Saturn and the rest was released on PC. The game peaked at the sequel and it was downhill from their. It started sucking BEFORE the PS1 series even finished. and my god that PS2 game. The reboot is the fastest selling it has been in a while so not sure what you are getting at.


you have to remember that Square cut a MAJOR load of content from the ps3 version of FF13 to fit on 3 360 discs

 

FF13 would've been a better overall game

we will never know what FF13 was REALLY supposed to be like

 

but what's done is done

im sorry but i still dont believe that, not that it matters anway. The game did ok sales wise.



Around the Network
enditall727 on 04 April 2013
Wright said:
enditall727 said:


They would've sold if they were QUALITY

 

and Wipeout gets a pass because NOTHING really sold on Vita at the time. It probably would've did good if it released when Vita hit$ 199 worldwide


^ So you're implying that Starhawk is not a quality game? D: Because it sold really, really bad, and if we follow this path of logic...

logic would show you that he didn't mention Starhawk..



Wright on 04 April 2013
enditall727 said:
Wright said:
enditall727 said:


They would've sold if they were QUALITY

 

and Wipeout gets a pass because NOTHING really sold on Vita at the time. It probably would've did good if it released when Vita hit$ 199 worldwide


^ So you're implying that Starhawk is not a quality game? D: Because it sold really, really bad, and if we follow this path of logic...

logic would show you that he didn't mention Starhawk..

 

No. It was said that Twisted Metal (among others) was dead because it didn't sold, because it lacked quality.


Following that logic, how can Starhawk be explained, then? The game has quality. But it has worse sales than Twisted Metal.



enditall727 on 04 April 2013
kain_kusanagi said:
enditall727 said:


you have to remember that Square cut a MAJOR load of content from the ps3 version of FF13 to fit on 3 360 discs

 

FF13 would've been a better overall game

we will never know what FF13 was REALLY supposed to be like

 

but what's done is done

Now it wasn't. That is a myth. FF13 was almost certainly finished and ready to go when at the last minute it was delayed to be ported to 360. It would have been the exact same game had it been a PS3 exclusive. Stuff gets cut from all games during development for many reasons. Everything that was cut from FF13 was most probably cut before it was ported, which is normal for game development. There is no evidence to suggest that the game was changed in any way due to the limited disc space of the 360. The 360 version was compressed and put on multiple discs and that's the only difference.

The most evidence we have is that it WAS cut to fit the 3 360 discs



enditall727 on 04 April 2013
Wright said:
enditall727 said:
Wright said:
enditall727 said:


They would've sold if they were QUALITY

 

and Wipeout gets a pass because NOTHING really sold on Vita at the time. It probably would've did good if it released when Vita hit$ 199 worldwide


^ So you're implying that Starhawk is not a quality game? D: Because it sold really, really bad, and if we follow this path of logic...

logic would show you that he didn't mention Starhawk..

 

No. It was said that Twisted Metal (among others) was dead because it didn't sold, because it lacked quality.


Following that logic, how can Starhawk be explained, then? The game has quality. But it has worse sales than Twisted Metal.


If i can't play a game fully then it lacks quality.

and why the fuck do you keep bringing up Starhawk? He said Twisted Metal, Socom and Wipeout



Wright on 04 April 2013
enditall727 said:


If i can't played a game fully then it lacks quality.

and why the fuck do you keep bringing up Starhawk? He said Twisted Metal, Socom, Wipeout

 


Excuse me...why are you talking in third person? o.O