Ill put multiplat beside them.  This is just so searching each one is easy on me. 

I haven't played Tomb Raider yet but based on what I've seen, it's odd that the score is closer to 90. I thought gaming journalists adore games like this...

Not all of them

At this point i think people and reviewers alike are burned out on this generation and are being harsher on games because they have already seen most of it.  They are ready for next gen to come and most importantly original games.

With similar titles like Uncharted and Batman rated in the 90s, this scenario stikes me as very, very odd.

Reviewers, maybe. People in general? I'm not certain.

It took me 21 1/2 hours to play though Tomb Raider. I loved every minute of it. It was a fantastic experience. I wouldn't change a thing. The exploration, puzzles, combat, story, writing, acting, graphics, music, sound, all of it was about as perfect as a game can get. It's a shame that it just gets compared to Uncharted because it's a completely different kind of game, IMHO a better game, and it deserves respect for what it's done. It really shouldn't get anything less than a solid 9/10, but for me it's a 10/10.

I've heard a few people say that now.  I havent got to play it yet.  been waiting for gamefly to send it to me, but hearing things like that makes me want to rush out and buy the game, which ill likely do anyways haha

Good Thread Jaywood! Just askin but maybe you should also have the top 10 for each console handheld, Exclusive, and/or Multiplats!

that make this thread very big than just top 10 cuz it'll hardly change imo

Whoops I meant to say that I'm suprised that the score isn't closer to 90. In any case I think in some respects Tomb Raider seems to out-Uncharted Uncharted. Especially in terms of treasure hunting.