1. You mentioned the "very real chance [you] were wrong [about nen being scum]" and "serious doubt [about your strong scum read of nen]". Regardless of my take on your role claiming question, if you are so hesitant to vote because of the risk of being wrong, what harm is there in quickly unvoting for someone you are highly considering isn't actually scum. Again, what "recent events" forced you to unvote now?

2.Yes, I think it is quite unlikely that at that point in time you'd have come up with such a theory. I don't think you were coached by scum to present said theory, but I think there was coaching that mentioned to/not to play up the newb card. I think you took the idea of playing the newb card and then pushed it against Seth.

3.You are going to have to show me where you think vets give newbs slack, because at the point you presented your theory I don't find any evidence of it. Your note is contradicting itself, plus you did:
"now that I've slept on it and thought about it a little more it's entirely possible that he's been coached by scum to say what he says? I don't remeber how long after the original question that he replied but I have a feeling there would be plenty of time for scum to interfere and give him an acceptable reply."

So you think that town is lazy and scum is tryhard?

raddishead said:
Yeah, I wanted the attention, so scum would think they could lynch me.

I scanned zero guilty.

2. I am not an idiot, I am perfectly capable of the level of reasoning to come up with the possibility of something like that being coached by scum. To be quite honest I would hope that most people in the game is capable of the same level of thinking. After all, it's not really that difficult to put that theory together and I am a little surprised that you continue to push that point. I mean, I understand the concept of applying presure and looking for cracks, but I am having a hard time believing that a simple deduction like that is so unheard of in mafia games that it warrents this kind of scrutiny. It's starting to feel like you're keeping something going just to muddle the waters.

Are you implying that Astro and Linkz are on different scum teams here?

So you're saying we should leave someone that is scum alive because he isn't a threat? Last time town did that mafia went in to have a flawless victory. I was starting to seriously consider the possibility that you and Linkz were town fighting it out but after this post I'm not so sure anymore >.>

This has to be one of the most oxymoronic statements I've read in a while haha. Unfortunately for Radish however, knowing him in real life means that I know he starts to act this way when he is uncomfortable (contradicting his own statements, acting forgetful etc.) so from where I am standing it seems like he had something to hide right from the moment he started to contradict himself. As such;

Unvote: DT (This vote is void now anyway considering the reasoning behind it)

Vote: Radishhead