Results are in and this is what you all voted for. here is your winners

1.  Uncharted 2 - 106 points

2.  Uncharted 3 - 77 points

3.  God of War III - 62 points

4.  Metal Gear Solid 4 - 52 points

5.  Demon's Souls - 43 points

 Since not too many people voted for series I just went ahead and included them.  It didnt really mess up any of the results because the top 5 won by a landslide.  Their wasnt any other game to even hit 30 points.  The only thing that might have changed was God of War 3 and Uncharted 3could have switched spots but that would have even been close.

its sad that there is no Red Dead Redemption in that list

Its weird that valkyria isnt on there considering how much hype it got from this forum...

Little Big planet 1 was absolutely jaw dropping to me when it released. The series has since lost that wonder, but I feel like it should have made the list.


Also, Uncharted 3 needs to GTFO.

It'll have a better chance on the new ip contest

I agree with the list, except for Uncharted 3. And, I'd put Demon's Souls second.

Uncharted three is a bad mark on the series. That game is a clusterf***

red dead redemption isnt a new IP, its a sequal to Red Dead Revolver. it released on PS2 but then Rockstar bought the IP and released RDR. i think its a "spiritual successor" and not a direct sequal. but it isnt considered a new IP. i hope people on here consider it to be on thoug