Because I felt it was all too convenient that he went from being sort of scummy to town and yet the information he had gathered meant that one other person was lying. As such, I felt he was a likely choice for the mafia Night killer and as such I could stop it. I didn't but I stand by my decision, especially since DT took so long to say what he did last Night (the few posts he commented on before finally saying what he did all took place after I asked him what he had done, I see no reason for him to have answered them back to front unless he was still thinking up what action he took last Night). He was also very on edge when I tracked him to Prof and has been playing the same way he does when scum, ie. insulting pretty much anyone that goes after him.

Also, rather than make a seperate post I'd like to point out I am gonna bounce now. I'll find the posts regarding the "town consensus" on who to kill tomorrow DT seeing as I can't find the page with the end of yesterDay on it at the moment. If anyone else can find who DS and Miz (as far as I can remember the only other players besides DT to make suggestions) said should be killed by Hat then please say so I don't have to look myself :P

D: Now i'm confused. Sorry, that post was supposed to be to ABC. 

what I meant was- does ABC think that because *HappyD* meant to put Trucks in the scum list, but instead put him in town- that *ABC* thinks that *HappyD* accidentally put *Trucks* in town because on some level *HappyD* know that *HappyD and Trucks* are scumbuddies. 

I didn't really understand it. 

The second part is to you though. 

I would lynch Tabaha with you guys if you find a flaw in my above post. 

In terms of item, i think the radioactive item part is almost certainly just something he made up in response to hat'z radioactive cock claim. 

The everyone visited prof scenario imo went like this. 

If Yoshiya is town (I'm defiantely not sure on right now).

He tracked me, and saw me visiting Prof. I was watching Prof and saw Trucks kill him.. I didn't see Tabaha there (Only bit i know is 100% true). If Tabaha is town (almost certianly false) then he was redirected elsewhere, or was blocked, or made up visiting prof to try and get me lynched thinking i was scum. 

If Tabaha is scum, then i didn't see him because he didn't visit and he was trying to clear Trucks. I think this scenario is far more likely, so the whole defending of Trucks, buddying with him, tryign to get players to vote him instead, makes me think he is our best shot for mafia. If we don't go after Hatz. 

If Yoshiya is scum, then he accused me of visiting prof to try and get me lynched, only fortunately for him, i actually did visit there. If he is scum, it would explain his roleblock not working, it would explain him not voting Trucks, and the mild buddying at the start of the game. Tabaha also came in to try and safe Trucks. 

Only time I have got a result and seen someone was night 2, where I only saw Trucks. 

Here I try.

I'm ok with this logic, but I think Hatz's radioactive cock and tabaha's ironman detector were both safeclaims, because DS's account is unshakeable.

Question, to do our due diligence, is there any case by which Tabaha may be telling the truth in that twist of actions?