TruckOSaurus on 09 November 2012
| theprof00 said: No, you misunderstand trucks. It cannot be reliably established that even a scum ff had to have taken a chance because for all we know, scum might have town pm descriptions. This I've now written 3 times, and it'll be the last time. Again, factually speaking, we cannot determine that any chance was taken by ff. Factually speaking, mario fits your same criteria, because if his trap was to get people to say they had a description so that he could catch them lying, then he'd be implicitly saying that his own pm has no description, hence why he didn't call ff a liar. Town mario could call out liars who have an explanatory pm. Scum mario (under your assumptions) would have to take a chance that there was no explanation. So, both made solid claims, one explicitly and one implicitly. Both are equally useless for determination of faction alliance, and especially neither is more town than another. This is further compounded that there may have already been townies expressing confusion regarding the map, and therefore scum could have already reasonably discovered that town have no explanation. |
I see what you're getting at but you and I have different ways of viewing the situation. So being the stubborn guy that I am, I'm still going to stay with my conclusions but I'll also let you interpret it as you wish to see it.
Signature goes here!
