Okay, yoshi looks much better than tabaha in the whole PM thing. tabaha said nothing either way until yoshi barely paraphrased the win condition. DT does look very opportunistic.

And then:

It is not fairly obvious to work out, as the wincon does not usually rule out a SK or any other direct threat to town. And mafia wouldn't be able to figure that out unless they were directly told such as well.

The rest reeks of covering yourself for not recognizing Rol as town due to what he said, when there was a day or so to linger on it. And jumping on me when I've done no wrong.

Okay, in retroperspective, I think scum could've filtered him as power by the way he asked me about my role day 2... this again would point at better players... I think he got a result that wasn't really worth mentioning.

Well, looking at things stand now I would prolly want to lynch DarkT... Well, I am still waiting for MBP, also yeah, some people need to engage a little more before I will place any vote.

patience you no have it seems

JUST WAIT!

I never said there's only one my good man, only that the chance that one of you is scum is extremely high. I'm sure this is a reasonable thought to take...

Fine fine, I take it back! You're posting the same way as you did last round when you were scum. Happy now? Sheesh! *jabs Linkz with his cane in a joking way*

But seriously though, you were much more involved with others in day one (starting on page 5 with 50ppp) and more at ease compared to last game. For me it was quite noticable, in a good way! Of course you still post in bunches, and I get that (I have two jobs and schooling as well... a skeleton's gotta make a living somehow!), but of course any little change in someone is noticable.

You did say the chance of spurge being scum is 25%, which is true only if one of the four(living) of us that voted pezus is scum. I'm a numbers guy, so I tend to focus on the implications of such statements. I get what you are actually trying to say though, which is it's quite likely for at least one mafioso to be on that lynch.

I would be highly surprised if Rol is scum. That's only possible if Trucks secretly gave mafia Town's wincon, and now he's trying to use it against me.

Thanatos seems likely, but I'm not sold on smeags either way.

Wait for what, and why must at least one of us be scum?

I didn't call smeags scum, you have.

piqued

First off, Linkz himself already addressed all this, which is what I wanted.  But now, here are my own thoughts (written before seeing Linkz's): 

Looking at Linkz's post, he says there may be a third party but there is nothing with kills aside from regular mafia unless something happened to the other kill.  This is compatible with the PM we received in the case of: 

1.  Survivor (and Linkz was talking about killing roles from other sources; if so this would be strangely worded IMO)
2.  Survivor-vig (basically this would be an SK that can win with town; not an unlikely role IMO, though unlikely to be in this particular game)
3.  Two mafia factions (ditto on likelihood)

Also, it is entirely possible that TOS provided mafia with the town PM, given his earlier comments and the lack of the promised example in the OP.  So I think it's too early by far to call Rol confirmed anything. 

As for Rol's mario post about third parties:  that means nothing.  The fact that you are trying to make it something is ... well ... I'm not sure. 

Thanks.

Two town reads and two scumspects?