I still fail to see how not including someone that you find suspicious makes someone else suspicious, both Spurge and DT have mentioned it at some point now and it seems to be the weakest argument in the world.

I do have to agree with Spurge over the fact that Smeags' content posting has been rather thin at times but then after the last game I am not sure what to make of that as at times I felt similarly about him.

I wanna hear more from MBP. He was very prevalent on day 1 but I seem to remember seeing a lot less of him day 2 which gives me the feeling that he was going all out in order to take down Pezus on day 1 (and thus hide behind the fact that mafia would never be that active at lynching a townie) and is now hiding slightly to prevent people from bringing that up again.

So you think out of the five (four now since Prof is dead) of you that voted for Pezus, not one of you is scum? Do you honestly think that? I find the thought of Pezus being lynched by all town players (regardless of reason) to be highly unlikely.

So, obvious thing to do first is check everyone mario listed as scum. Thanatos, Linkz, Smeags and me.

Regarding me, I'm pretty sure I'm not scum.

For Thanatos, the way mario listed him here makes me think he's not. Why didn't he list them with the other 3? Might as well be a trick to avoid suspicions on Thanatos. I need to think a bit about this one.

For Linkz, looks like he did the last vote for mario's lynch. Was it to avoid mario revealing important stuff unintentionally?

For Smeags it starts be interesting. He did vote for No Lynch in day 1, just as mario did.

*pats SpurgeonRyan on the head*

See?! This is what I'm talking about.

We also mustn't forget Linkz complete 180 to this playstyle from last game. Before he was a *smiles* Grumpasaurus that only posted in bunches. But now he seems more at ease and posts more evenly throughout the day. What does this mean? Who knows, but its something.

Also, let me see this post of Man-Bear-Pig's if you will...

It wasn't that you targeted Rol specifically, but it's the fact that you're finally getting what I've been saying. There's an extremely likely chance of one of the remaining four being scum. And now we must narrow the field down...

Oh... there's MBP's thread. Not very telling at all actually.

Yoshiya. Stahp. You misunderstand. 

It's not that I ALONE find him suspicious, it's that a lot of town thought one of them was, and he put in neither. Not to mention, if I was scum, then I'm not going to throw in all my scummates into my suspicion pile, in case I end up not being voted- like Spurge was round 1. You have also decided to ignore the other point I threw in to support my point, about Nacho. (oh and the weakest argument in the world is "You have good/bad grammar, must be scum. Or, you voted me, and as im not scum, you must be scum.")

I like your point on MBP though, it's similar to Rol, except with greater lurking, and less original suspicion on him. 

Link me to a single post where I said I didn't trust Stefl after he revealed his role.

My point on your potential scumminess was shown within the original point, similarly to Rol. People's suspicions on you have already been said, and the amount of times Rol's lurking has been pointed out similarly. Adding more to it would have been just regurgitating others points, something which I did at the start of the last game i played, before i was told it was redundant and just made me look suspicious. 

Your last point on the information raises my eyebrows though, I have nothing to hide that I wouldn't be happy sharing, so please go ahead and tell us all. 

*sigh* It's already been said (even by Stefl himself I would like to point out) that just because Stelf saw him go to the person that happened to die, doesn't mean that he was the person that killed him. I didn't think he had played like scum for the most part and seeing as his fakeclaim would have to go to someone as well in order to scan it was totally possible that Mario was still town. Ok so as it turned out he was the one that killed him but we had no conclusive evidence to say otherwise so unlike you guys that are willing to jump on people for the smallest reason, I was factoring in his play as well which was like his play last game when he was town aligned.

Also, before this Rol lurk thing goes any further, has he been around on the rest of the site? Would be a good way to see if he was telling the truth about not being able to go online or not.