Mantle has been acting like a crazy person for the entire game, and I refuse to believe that I'm the only person here who thought he was very suspicious.

Spurge made that case as to why he couldn't be mafia too - is it completely unheard of for mafia to throw each other under the bus in order to improve their own standing? Not that it matters, since Mantle is town

Why pezus night 1?

He was the player that I thought was most likely to be mafia going into night 1 - I can't remember my exact reasoning now

I think town would steamroll if we mass roleclaim.(minus the doc who should claim Vanilla)

Or we can just lynch spurge, radish can scan into the Twilight Sparkle group, doc protects radish, I die tonight,(you're welcome) and you guys will have a great idea what to do in the coming Days. Only trouble is if mafia have a roleblocker or some type of misdirection.

Why spurge and not Stefl? Everyone has been a fan of the even distribution idea, so it's unlikely that there were four Pinkie Pie townies and a "true" Pinkie Pie mafia that lied out of that group. On the other hand, three town Rarities with a mafia that lied into a different group is more probable.

Or we can lynch prof, with much of the rest being the same. Or zero for that matter.

We can't ignore these results - we either lynch Spurge, or we lynch Stefl. I don't mind who

Spurge it is. If he flips town, you're either insane or mantle is a godfather. If he flips mafia, hooray!

Vote: spurgeonryan

....Dude scanned me after conj flipped scum.

Simply can't believe it. Thought he scanned me at first since he didn't seem that suspicious of me during day 2.

As I said, it doesn't matter who I scanned. I was simply more convinced that spurge was town than you :)

I really wouldn't mind that either. I'm banking on 2 mafia in his group, and he's the most likely mastermind to orchestrate the claims necessary to pull off such a thing.