I really don't think it's pointless, and I'm pretty sure I could exploit this game... pretty badly if I wanted to, especially if the name claims were ALL mane ponies.

No. It is far from pointless actually. So why did you become suspicious of me when I was talking about this very early on? Now you bring it up again and it is suddenly OK?

say we lynched the element of generosity -Rarity. Since there's only one element of generosity, and one element per scum, the other rarity's could claim and pretty much be confirmed towns.

Mario actually nailed it with his most recent post.

Pondering over it while I was bored in class.  The idea hit me like a brick. Especially when I remembered the correlation between elements and Ponies, and that there were only one of each element regardless of the number of copied ponies. 

I was one step behind you in the flavor I guess.

I severly doubt it's going to do any good, but it can't do any harm unless everyone gets hung up on it.

Rainbow Dash.

It's really simple. I don't have a solid case against him. I just think he is mafia. isn't mafia game also about feelings and intiution?

And my feeling won't change for now if that is the answer you were looking for. 

Okay.

Actually I was wondering what Soleron could have done to give you the opposite feeling, but fair enough.

It took me all of a minute to figure out not one, but two methods to break hat's "exploit". Good thing I'm not mafia, eh.

Rarity

oh  this game will break . And I did go over counter measures F-F may have taken, like perhaps all Rainbow Dashes were town, or 2 of the same ponies were scum. However F-F specifically stated that the elements are scum, so that would make those measures impossible since it's impossible for the same element to exist twice or for one element to not exist at all. That equals one scum per set of copies.

Best part is F-F can't punish me coz he said we can claim all we want.