Same post, different bold.

You say your intentions were to annoy Noctis.

Here you say that you were suggesting that he could be a member of mafia and I am looking a bit defensive.

Explain then, how is it that you thought he was hinting at being mafia (which would be ridiculous) but then you say that you were trying to annoy Noctis.

It's not a contradiction- I've actually done nothing but repeat the same idea with slightly different wording to this debate every time, in the hope that you'd eventually understand what I'm trying to say. Here's how it goes:

1) Noctis posts his signing-in message; an image of Dr Evil. Dr Evil is, as his name suggests, evil, so I decided to make a joke about it.

2) That joke came in the form "Which element do you represent?" - ie. I was "suggesting that he could be Mafia" - not a serious suggestion- a jokey one, because, as you already said, it would be ridiculous to believe that Noctis would just give up on his first post and admit being mafia-aligned. I never said that I thought he was hinting at being mafia - it was my first post in the round as well as his, so I decided to make a light-hearted comment about it. 

3) I say that it would "annoy" Noctis, because he'd have to respond- I was going to use his response to my joke to try to size up his tone/playstyle in this round from the outset. Not only was this situation nothing suspicious in the slightest, it was actually some subtle, early scumhunting.

For the repeated refusal to let this issue dissolve, we can already see that it's taken attention away from the actual scumhunting - which other players are trying to do, but without much success due to this ridiculous debate. I refuse to believe that you don't have some benefit to gain from completely distracting half the town, effectively making Day 1 useless. At least a couple of those trying to capitalise on the situation are more than likely going to be mafia-aligned, in my eyes.

Unvote: No Lynch

Vote: Mantle

FoS Pezus

FoS Moreno

Okay, in the first post, I checked in, what's wrong with that?

In the second one, I made an off topic question, I wanted to know why the show is popular, nothing else.

So what'sthe problem, then I had a trip all Sunday so it was impossible for me to post. That's it.

Actually, aboout Radish, I only didn't like his sudden change of topic back them, but YOU are looking for weak lynching excuses.

FoS Mario.

@radish
I said it was flimsy, but now youre trying to pretend like doctor isnt the first part of doctor evils name?

Radish why did you ask his name when you later said that mafia are netter off knowing who the characters are? You remember that ff said meta would be impossible right?

Tbh I don't think that Doctor Evil thing showing he was inquiring about doctors to be worth following.

Also, I'm still not sure why Radish thinks that the mafia are better off knowing the names of people? If we know say most of the Rainbow Dashs we can group them together and investigate them as a seperate group making it easier to work out which one is mafia. Also, if we know multiples of one character then the town ones instantly become safer because by killing them off the mafia lowers the list of suspects with that character. I think Radish is trying to cover up what he worked out after saying that.

HoS Radish

Oh that's quite clever- I didn't really think about the character himself (durr "Dr" evil)- I only said it as a joke

When I asked which element he represented, I was joking (remember, the elements of harmony are the players that we're trying to lynch). When I said the mafia are better of knowing who the characters are, I was being half-serious however- there is a link between my character and my role, but it's unlikely to be much use to the mafia team, to be fair. 

So just to confirm, you're happy with a mass character claim?

@ yoshi
Ya i know the dr thing isnt anything. But it is interesting that he calls me mafia for it, ignoring and avoiding the more important point that he asked for something that he admits would help mafia, in a game where meta wont help anyone.. that looks like misdirection to me.
Similarly he says "I questioned doctor evil picture because as the name suggests, he is evil. " misdirection .
Noc is known for hinting at his roles.

I think perhaps noc is a good target for watching. Dont specifically watch him, but watcher please consider him.

To be perfectly honest I don't quite understand what you mean by that haha

@Yoshiya: I mean would you be happy if everyone claimed what character they were?