wow that's a pretty massive misunderstanding of the rules of the game lol. You can see now that this game is a lot harder than it appeared?

Just curious though, so you thought you were unlynchable? What would you have said if someone voted for you? Did you think the day just ended with no death?

That still doesn't make much sense. A townie could simply vote each person and if the vote doesn't count then the other person would be confirmed town. But now you know how it works, so moving on.

pezus said you seemed to know a lot about the game already because you have much at stake if you slip up [and get lynched]. Yes, anyone getting lynched is bad for their respective team, but mafia having fewer numbers means each member is worth more than a townie. Thus if you're mafia you have more of an incentive to do research so as not to hinder your team.

Why do I feel like you're just agreeing with me >_>

Please read the game on here:
http://cataldo.freeshell.org/mafia/mafiascum04.swf

You just said you thought townies' votes on a townie wouldn't count. So why would you ask for a reason for a vote?

I believe this should be a complete and up to date votals: 

In no particular order within the lists:

Feeling town:

Soleron - Good analysis on Pezus, argument with pezus seems genuine.

Yoshiya - Posts like this (http://gamrconnect.vgchartz.com/post.php?id=4744855) give me the "confused newbie" vibe, which suggests town in a first game

Hatmosa - Nothing particular that stands out, but I'm getting a generally town-vibe from almost everything he's posted so far this round. Obviously liable to change

Linkz - Seems genuine enough; might be playing it a little safe at the moment (regarding lynches), but I find that's how Linkz likes to play in the early days. He is doing a lot of questioning, and definitely isn't hiding in the background, which makes me think town-aligned at the moment.

Unsure:

c03n3nj0 - the only player that seems to have read my first post correctly, but the fact that nobody else did suggests that it could be very unobvious to an "untrained eye" - ie. there's always the possibility that he's been discussing it in a Quicktopic.

Pezus - Got a bit defensive when being questioned by Soleron ("Why would you vote for me and not the other..."), but his stance on No Lynch seems genuine enough (if a little dangerous for the first day)

Zero129 - Is it just me that's unnerved by the ":P"s in this post? Could be the new-player mafia (aligned) nerves kicking in? (http://gamrconnect.vgchartz.com/post.php?id=4744935)

Spurge - Haven't got a read on him yet- his mafia playing seems as erratic and unpredictable as all his other posts on VGC!


Maybe mafia:

Moreno - Comes back into game after a pretty long absence, and appears to try intimidating Mario for "condemn[ing] me (Moreno) on those two posts? Really?"This alignment may change when he comes back and reads up on the rest of the thread like he claimed he would.

Noctis - In the posts I read through to make this analysis, I didn't see a single one from him - that can't be a good sign, right? Could change as more posts come in


Mantle - COMING SOON (tm) - Currently "Maybe mafia"
Stefl - COMING SOON (tm) - Currently "Unsure"
Mario - COMING SOON (tm) - Currently "Unsure"


@Prof: "Oh well, I might as well just say it too. I do feel there is a legitimate slip in there as well, and that is one of being interested in the character details of a 'doctor'. I wasn't going to say it earlier because I felt it was flimsy. It is still flimsy, but I also didn't expect to be asked what I meant."

^ Considering that was aimed at a post that I made, I'm really confused - I don't remember even typing the word "doctor" in this round, let alone asking for the character details of one

Radish if you want to soon™ - it's alt-0153

Now to what really matters: I totally disagree with your reasoning on Yoshiya. I just want you to remember Wiibox in his first round, he got a free pass until he got incidentaly cought doing his evil deeds~ but until then a lot of people gave him a free pass for being in the appearance of a newbie town.

Spurge, I don't know if I wasn't clear... umm... I wanted to ask you if you can point out a post were pezus calls Noctis lurking.

So much stuff to process from my last comment :G
I'd say since I last posted my suspicions of Mantle have gone down slightly but I am still not too sure about Radish. The fact that he has posted reasons for his feelings behind every other player but simply stated what side he believes Mantle is on who from what I can tell has been the biggest person to question him seems a bit suspicious. Almost feels as if he is trying to avoid putting down reasons that will make people re-look into that debate.