I just bought the HD edition for PS3 on Amazon for $21 CDN.

I've never played these games before, but I heard they are really really good.

Which should I play first? I know they have no relation, but which one to save for last?

Forgive me Playstation fans, I'm not sure why I waited so long to play these games.

Play ICO first. I think it gives a slightly better understanding for when you play SOTC.

ditto, the ending of sotc is so much better if you've played ico.

ICO first.

Last Guardian last .

Play ICO first because it was released first

Play Shadow of Colossus first because timeline wise it is probably before events that take place in ICO

See you can't lose no matter which you play first... cause they are both great and it doesn't matter in which order you play them.

Yeap but you understand better Shadow of Colossus playing Ico fisrt.

To have the best experience plays Ico first.

Yupp,atleast in EUROPE.

Two or three months ago Since January in US.

Yup, ICO first.

Ico first, then SotC then Ico again, then SotC again, and repeat.