By using this site, you agree to our Privacy Policy and our Terms of Use. Close

Forums - General Discussion - Mafia Round 43 - WipEout

pezus said:
mantlepiecek said:

What made you so sure of him not being a cop? Unless it's the result : but that is exactly what made him sure townie in my eyes. I mean his result is accurate. If I say I am a gunsmith and scan a vigilante as a person with guns, I would be accurate too and probably a confirmed townie in the vigs eyes.

Because it was half-assed. And no cop would be that bad. Simple as that. This is prof we're talking about here, not some newbie who decides to target radish night 1 (stefl lulz, but he didn't...so he is excused)

Personally, I thought he was x-shot and only had like two shots at it.



Around the Network
pezus said:
BUT it would be nice if prof actually answered questions once in a while. Like who he was going to vote for a while back.

What do you think? Who are the remaining two scum?



mantlepiecek said:

This post. Now tell me, since Notstan was the second choice, how did you feel during that time thinking that "mantle is scum, notstan is scum, mantle is hard at lynching notstan, this all makes sense too!"

Reply please.

My thought process was more like "If I can't get Mantle lynched like I want, I guess I have to accept NotStan's fate".

 

mantlepiecek said:

But at least your posts haven't been oppurtunistic like mario's.

Could you elaborate about this, please?

 

theprof00 said:
Sadly i am not a cop.
I wanted to see who would attack the cop and who would want to see my results.
Thats all i have for now, just want to check in to make sure nobody was waiting on me to talk.

Seriously? If that was the case why didn't you wait until Jo was online before posting this?




Nintendo still doomed?
Feel free to add me on 3DS or Switch! (PM me if you do ^-^)
Nintendo ID: Mako91                  3DS code: 4167-4543-6089

supermario128 said:
mantlepiecek said:

This post. Now tell me, since Notstan was the second choice, how did you feel during that time thinking that "mantle is scum, notstan is scum, mantle is hard at lynching notstan, this all makes sense too!"

Reply please.

My thought process was more like "If I can't get Mantle lynched like I want, I guess I have to accept NotStan's fate".

mantlepiecek said:

But at least your posts haven't been oppurtunistic like mario's.

Could you elaborate about this, please?


On the second point, you have been on my tail since day 3, I consider it opportunistic.

On the more important first point, why did you say he was the second choice? If it was accepting Notstan's fate then he wouldn't be a second choice, now, would he?

Contradictory statements. If he was the second choice then you wouldn't be accepting his fate.



mantlepiecek said:

On the more important first point, why did you say he was the second choice? If it was accepting Notstan's fate then he wouldn't be a second choice, now, would he?

Contradictory statements. If he was the second choice then you wouldn't be accepting his fate.

Yes I would be. If I couldn't get you lynched then I would have to accept that he was getting lynched, even if he was my second choice. Just because he was my second choice doesn't mean I felt strongly about it. If I did I probably would have pursued him a lot more, like I did to you.

 

Also, I still think a Mantle/ Prof scum team is most likely. It is interesting how they both say each other are obvious town, or close to that. Also Mantle accepted that Prof was cop without any hesitation just because he claimed Mantle was town? Mantle didn't even question him at all. I just hope that Pezus and Jo don't fall for this act.




Nintendo still doomed?
Feel free to add me on 3DS or Switch! (PM me if you do ^-^)
Nintendo ID: Mako91                  3DS code: 4167-4543-6089

Around the Network
supermario128 said:
mantlepiecek said:

On the more important first point, why did you say he was the second choice? If it was accepting Notstan's fate then he wouldn't be a second choice, now, would he?

Contradictory statements. If he was the second choice then you wouldn't be accepting his fate.

Yes I would be. If I couldn't get you lynched then I would have to accept that he was getting lynched, even if he was my second choice. Just because he was my second choice doesn't mean I felt strongly about it. If I did I probably would have pursued him a lot more, like I did to you.

 

Also, I still think a Mantle/ Prof scum team is most likely. It is interesting how they both say each other are obvious town, or close to that. Also Mantle accepted that Prof was cop without any hesitation just because he claimed Mantle was town? Mantle didn't even question him at all. I just hope that Pezus and Jo don't fall for this act.

Well. What would you have done if you were said to be town by a cop? What would you question the claimed cop?



pezus said:
mantlepiecek said:
pezus said:
BUT it would be nice if prof actually answered questions once in a while. Like who he was going to vote for a while back.

What do you think? Who are the remaining two scum?

Probably prof and one other who I am not as sure of. 

Who is that other guy? Come one, don't hold back. Honestly prof should have listed his scumpects too.



pezus said:
mantlepiecek said:
pezus said:

Probably prof and one other who I am not as sure of. 

Who is that other guy? Come one, don't hold back. Honestly prof should have listed his scumpects too.

No, I meant that I am not sure who that other guy is :). Could be you, j0 or mario. I guess I have a 50% chance of pointing at scum this time around, so I'd hate to be wrong again

So you are saying you want prof to be lynched today and then think about whom to lynch tomorrow or something?



mantlepiecek said:

Well. What would you have done if you were said to be town by a cop? What would you question the claimed cop?

For a cop to wait this long before coming forward with the claim, yes. Yet, you accepted him right away and didn't even consider any other options.

I would feel comfortable lynching either Mantle or Prof, but I am more sure about Mantle.




Nintendo still doomed?
Feel free to add me on 3DS or Switch! (PM me if you do ^-^)
Nintendo ID: Mako91                  3DS code: 4167-4543-6089

supermario128 said:
mantlepiecek said:

Well. What would you have done if you were said to be town by a cop? What would you question the claimed cop?

For a cop to wait this long before coming forward with the claim, yes. Yet, you accepted him right away and didn't even consider any other options.

I would feel comfortable lynching either Mantle or Prof, but I am more sure about Mantle.

lol, it's not like he got a guilty investigation. So why should he have come forward with his role if he doesn't have a guilty investigation?