You only listed two possible options, so I was merely listing a third option that was more likely.

True, but who is to say it couldn't be the same thing this round? The only difference is we have a coroner as opposed to flips after the janitor dies.

The coroner claim is pretty convenient, but I'm not going to theorize that he's in fact not a coroner.
Also as an aside, there are different kinds of coroners iirc, depending on the mod.

One is that the coroner has to pick the person being janitored, the other is that he unveils automatically, and the other is that he investigates someone who has previously died. I could be wrong about those things, but I'm pretty confident in that.

So, being as it is, I'm willing to give him a few nights. If he is indeed a coroner, he's a likely kill target, and with doc protection could confirm him somewhat. Additionally, if he's one of these variable roles as opposed to the auto coroner, then we might see a janitor happen tonight, which could validate him somewhat.

I'll not that I don't actually find him that suspicious, just that there are other options beside coroner being a mafia safeclaim.

Maybe the janitored deaths don't flip with the death of the janitor this round. That would make the coroner role not only believable, but very necessary.

So that means that the results might only be revealed to the coroner only?

Very good point, but why did you even bring up the point about the possibility of not reading your PM in the first place? I realize you said you did, but there were others who thought you might not have as well. You are fully capable of "making sense" as mafia. I just have a feeling about you. (Yes, I know that isn't very convincing) I'm not excused of anything, but I had a reason for not posting since I was out of state Sunday night and almost all of Monday.

I am leaning towards pro town for Spurge (only slightly), so it wouldn't make sense for mafia to help out a town player when they could sit back and watch him dig a deeper hole.

Like I already said, if I didn't mention it directly I meant to. It should have been obvious that I was going to play more serious this round. I'm pretty sure I did mention it somewhere though.

Yet, you said you would possibly lynch me because I was being more serious?

But why would scum want to bring that much attention to them and spawn this debate? It almost makes me less suspect of him. But I will keep watching.

This is the same thing I am wondering about Spurge. He is online all of the time, but has barely psot here in the last day.

Here this is where I figured it out.

http://wiki.mafiascum.net/index.php?title=Janitor

http://wiki.mafiascum.net/index.php?title=Coroner

Here is the jist:

"The Janitor is an anti-Town role who "cleans up the body" after its kill, thus preventing players from learning anything about the player when they flip. At daybreak, it is simply said that the player died with no information about their role or their alignment."

"A Coroner is a role that can target a dead player to discern information about them. The typical function of a Coroner is such that they learn the full-reveal flip of the player in a limited- or No Reveal game. If a game is not advertised as having anything other than full role reveals, a Coroner probably implies the existence of a Janitor. Coroners are generally Town-aligned."