I like avatars that don't change much. That's key, no change. Should not be too dark or light and it should have a prominent feature that makes it stick out so it can be recognized. Topless women and "Good", I stress the word "good" Hentai is always a welcome sight. The Furry thing is regrettable which can can be a good thing or a bad thing but people always tend to focus on the oddness, which is understandable.

Badonkadonkhr - 8.3
bdbdbd - 8
BenKenobi66 - 7
Bodhesatva - 10
Bonafide732 - 9.1
BrainBoxLtd - 8.6
Canyarion - 7
cAPSLOCK - 9.1
celine - 9
ckmlb - 5
cool48 - 7.9
Dallinor - 8.9
Damstr8 - 6.8
DarkNight_DS - 8.6
DMeisterJ - 7.5
DonWii - 9
dweti - 8.5*
eab - 8
Endurance - 8
everdom - 7.9
fazz - *3
Flymolo - 8
FJ-Warez - 8.5
Gamerace - 9
gengka - 9
GGE - 9
Gobias - 9
Goosegaws - 9
grandmaster192 - 9.2
HappySqrl - 9
Hawk - 8
Ishy - 8.4*
IcingDeathWrath - 6
IllegalPaladin - 8.6
ItsaMii - 10
Joemanji - 9.1
John Lucas (also known as Jaylu) - 9
josenieves01 - 8.01
Kingsora_be - 6.5
koopatrooper - 8.5
kirby007 - 8.9*
Lafiel - 7
leo-j - 7
LISMDK - 7.1
Lolita - 8
ManCandy - 8.86
mesoteto - 7.6
Mnementh - 7.9
MontanaHatchet - 6
Mr Reseeeti - 7
mrstickbal - 4
Naznatips - 9
NeoRatt - 7.2
Nintendo_Fanboy - 8.5
okeydokey - 10
Onna76 - 9.75
PDF - 7.6
phalanx - 8
pichu_pichu - 8.3
Pikaboo - 8
pntsurf1 - 8.2
ps3unleashed - 6
rickthestick - 6
Relias - 8.2
roadkillers - 8.9
RCTjunkie - 8
Rolstoppable - 9.8*
RoomForOneMore - 8.8
routsounmanman - 8.2
Rubang B - 11
segajon - 8.4
SeriousWB - 9.5
shams - 10
Shastaman - 8
sieanr - 9
silentwolf - 3
skeezer - 8
slicktrick - *9.75
smbu2000 - 4
soriku - 8
souixan - 9
Stof - 10
superchunk - 9.4
Supermariounivers - 9
Sqrl - 9
ssj12 - 8.9
takeru - 8
takkxy - 7
The_Vagabond7 - 8.5
tk1989 - 7.5
TomaTito - 8.1
tombi123 - 7.123
twesterm - 8.9
TWRoO - 9.due
vaio - 6
VAMP - 9
Vengi - 7
Weebs - 9.0
weezy - 8.4 (old one was a 9.2)
Words of Wisdom - 8.9*
xcosmarx - 7
Xeo_842 - 8.1
XOMANIAC - 6
Xponent - 8
xstonexcold316x - 7.9
Elgefe02 - 0.02

*Have upgraded to a better avatar and been relisted with new avatar score.