Jealousy is obviously the source of this hate in most cases. For the same reasons people hate on games like Halo, both series just won't stop selling.

Here's what probably goes through their minds: "How can they release game after game each year without actually experiencing a significant decline? Why must we keep coming up with new IP's while they can just re-release the same games over and over again while their ignorant customers keep buying them no matter their content? They were lucky to come up with that specific franchise. Until they have shown that they can create new successful IP's (casual ones such as Brain training and the Wii series obviously doesn't count), they shall forever be known as cowards."

Another possibility would be that they really want to love Nintendo for whatever reason but can't given their current existing IP's.

I'm satisfied but maybe that is because I am insanse with the membrane.

What is the difference this time around?

During this 3 year time period, there has been a release of a new handheld system, that got a 3D title for it, and will be getting a new 2D title for it.  And then add on top of that, since you mentioned NSMBU, that there there will be a new home console released.  End result is a number of new Mario titles, which so happens to correspond with Nintendo deciding to have actual Mario titles on their systems early, closer to launch.  And you had a 2D Mario title released later in the lifecycle of the Wii (a 2D one).

Are you missing the fact that two new systems are part of Nintendo's serving the market here, and they were getting Mario titles early?  

It is a word, with a definition, that is actually a word.  There isn't some sort of official government department that creates language.  Languages starts out as slang, and then becomes more common usage.  Once it gets to a critical level, it enters a dictionary.  

But those two aspects that you said are indeed evolution. So now you are just stepping on your own toes.

no im not, i never criticized that those to aspects. and when i stated that nintendo games didnt evolve i ment didnt evolve in every other apsects (which are a lot pf aspects) 

Now you are saying Nintendo  Games as a whole don't evolve? I thought we were talking about why people hated Mario not Nintendo?

oh sorry i ment mario. dont know how i wront nintendo games 

OK, then. 

Mario can not evolve to the point where it's not Mario. There are certain things that need to stay. Level Design and Graphics are perfectly fine for evolution purposes and keeping things fresh. Even changing the music up would be nice. Not much else, though.

in your opinion, but i really think there is much to do, but they arent happening which honestly saddens me. i stated before i love mario, i just explain why people might hate it. honestly i wish the franshice could reach its full potential. i dont think its wrong to critisize i game you like or love even if its critisizing as hard as i critized mario games on this thread, but i nocited some people on here just dont seem to accept that. im not saying you are im just saying the some people on here are like that