Isn't it based on how big the budget is?

i would say so but i have no clue how big a fable budget or a heavy rain budget or whatever is that's why i wonder how he exactly knows which games aaa are.

High-quality games with high budget.

and who defines high quality? you because you prefer a different kind of games to someone else? i prefer dance central more than little big planet, dance central is aaa hooray! and fable is aaaa lol

heavy rain and maybe beyond are not even games for me does this count as -a then?

Sweet! Hopefully a next-gen game.

For that we have experts. I don´t like RPGs that much but The Witcher 2 and Xenoblade Chronicles have convinced me, and I bought them because the reviews where good. Most reviewers know what there jobs, and they say if a game is good or not.

most say dance central is the best game in that genre. can't be so bad then (sure it won't get scores like halo or so because there are always people who hate a dance game but this doesn't mean the quality is bad). people who score it bad only do it because they hate this kind of game in general but can we trust such a review then for a game which is very good in what it does?

Did you guys read the Original Post? This is all I am saying. Just go and read it again and maybe..

halo? ok

How many Halo games on the 360 is that now 6?