So, not really related to real life countries? It's fictional?

Tagged.

^It's useful, and it makes perfect sense to me at least.

I thought Wonk was scum because baalz said thanks, I thought it was baalz saying Wonk threw him under the bus, I should have been more careful in doubtin Wonk.

But, I suspected a Prof-Wonk-Baalz scumteam, so people saying I'm buddy-buddy with prof are mistaken.

I believe CARTEL to be mafia faction 1. The reason is that linkz probs doesn't want us to know for sure that there are 2 scumteams, but the 3-kill even can really only lead to that thought in a 20-man game. Cult is iffy because if cult leader dies, it's pretty much win for town.

Baalz' move is really scummy.

Baalz town: He lies miller, but causes his no-lynch so people know who is who. He wastes his ability and in so doing causes night and townie deaths. I don't buy that. Another question, why did he lie miller? Why didn't he lie another role? Is miller that common? Couldn't he lie another role? Also, the consequences of all this is that town is even more confused. Is he an X-shot, is he scum. I just see meager benefit to town and mostly benefit to mafia, pre-emptive and actual... Plus, he lied.

Baalz scum: He claims miller in hopes to evade a scan. He chooses Robb Stark because it's the safest townie name, but just after realizes how silly that was, since it was possible that another townie was Robb Stark. Those saying scum can't be unlynchable are failing to see that 1) There may be fewer scum, so it was a balancing move by linkz and 2) It's most likely a 1-shot ability.

HoS Baalz

Mario is grasping at staws with Spurge.

HoS Mario

Korppi is too quiet, too smart. I suspect him to be doing a lot of detective work in the mafia QTs. After seeing his smarts in the name the vgchartz member thread, I can tell you the guy is a brain.
FoS Korrpi

FoS Final-Fan on the orthodox post. He is likely in scum faction 2, otherwise why cover your tracks?

Vote Baalz
Let's get rid of one scum team and reduce the # of night kills by one.

Would you care to elaborate on this? Who do you find suspicious?

Hatz, he never had to "know" that another miller existed. Claiming miller will usually get you lynched with or without a counter claim. Also, I believed without a doubt he was scum as well, but you are forgetting one very important detail. Baalz wasn't lynched yesterday because he is unlynchable and for some reason you keep on ignoring that fact. Someone who is unlynchable cannot be scum. It simply breaks the game for the town.

*ROLLS ON FLOOR LAUGHING*

That was by far the stupidest vote I have seen in the entire time I have played mafia.

The more discussion the better Hatz. We can look back at conversations day one AND continue to ask new questions. I think we can handle a bit of multi tasking.

I did a bit of analyzing. Mantle was the first one that caught my attention with his defense on Prof when he got two votes on him. He said Prof might have a powerful role which could help us, but why was he assuming so early on and why was he even defending someone over a joke vote. Prof wasn't even close to being lynched.

Also, I don't really care for their lists. I prefer to make my own.

Sorry for taking so long to get back, I was golfing.

Now, to clear things up for people.

A.) I had absolutely no clue there was a miller (and to be honest, wasn't really expecting that). Claiming miller alone was an attempt to get people to vote for me. These votes and peoples thoughts about my claim provide a lot of information. I wanted to go further than that, however. I also fakeclaimed Robb Starks. Not knowing much about the series, I looked into the Stark house (since I myself am a Stark) and picked none other than Robb, figuring somebody would say that is who they are. It was all a massive attempt to get votes. I did not care if I was lynched (but I still wanted the day to continue on yesterday so we could further discuss it...asking to get votes taken off was an attempt to prevent somebody like Spurge doing exactly what he did...hammering me).

B.) No, I don't reflect my lynch on anybody (that's sorta a silly question). No, I don't only have X-Shots. I can never be lynched in this game, which is why I am quite surprised that mafia did not kill me last night.

C.) Vote: Hatmoza You have been playing this game long enough and are smart enough not to make a mistake that dumb as town. Mafia would never, ever, ever, ever have an unlynchable. It is game breaking.

It was pretty bad, I agree. How does getting rid of one person equal getting rid of an entire scum team, Happy?

Plus, I can't see any scenario in which Baalz is an unlynchable scum.

HoS: Happy