I played chapter 2 last night with free aim instead of soft lock. I need to tweak the aiming speed because it feels horribly slow. The laggy movement and his dramatic slow dive aborting when he brushes a wall don't help either. Nor the camera being thrown around all the time leaving me disoriented when the action starts again.
Maybe I've grown old, this does not bring back pleasant memories of the game play in Max Payne 1.
Max Payne's narrative will keep me going rather then the game play.

Only in part 2 myself as I have been doing everything, but gaming. I still imagine the multiplayerwill be sick. The level after the whore house is pretty sweet and the boat and dock llevel are cool. Not to mention I thought the Branco building was fun (spoilers) especially when burning. The game does really look good.

Is the police station level ever going to end? I'm getting bored of shooting bullet sponges while running forward through the nonsensical layout. This is the worst level so far. The bus depot was pretty boring too.

The Branco building made a lot more sense, although not his dumb route while the building was on fire. It made for pretty pictures anyway.
Boat level and running around the bad neighbourhoods in Sao Paolo are my favorites.

Funny, I just beat thoe police station last night and I totally agree it was dragging on too long. I got pretty mad at the cover system and aiming system too by the end playing on hard with no Auto aim. Because Max often dies as you probably noticed even when he still has pain killers in certain situations. Or how the slow down camara often is too slow to save you by shooting the guy who shot you. It was fine early, but by late in the game it got more challenging and the flukes I mentioned killed me a lot. I did beat the game and the airport is fun, but due to the problems you kind of just want it to end. Unfortunate as I really enjoyed the first to parts. I agree the story really is one of the best things in the game. I did find Max a little too depressing, but the adult theme and the fact the story relates to crime rings in real life actually is really cool. I still say it is better than gears 2 and 3, but the bugs just bring it down if you set the game to hard and autoaim.  still give it an 8.5/10. 

I got through finally then went to bed at the start of the airport. I was kinda afraid it would be another boring drag after it started off in the baggage handling area.

You're pretty generous with your score, I give it a 6.5. The story and especially Max's monologues are great but I'm tired of the nonsense level layouts that so many tps/fps games fall victim too. I much prefer the level layout from something like SH downpour.
The overuse of effects and camera wobble during cutscenes make it tiring to watch at times and I still haven't got used to the laggy movement scheme or found a good setup for aiming.

The one last chance to save yourself by shooting your attacker camera is a nice addition but it often doesn't work. It makes some mini bosses trivial since you only need one shot in this mode instead of pumping them full of lead. It always leaves you exposed lying on the floor afterwards with pretty much most of my health gone by the time he scrambles back up and into cover. And half the time it triggers with something obstructing your view and you just have to wait till time runs out before you can start again.

I'm using shoot dodge less and less. If you don't get everyone you're pretty much dead while trying to get back to your feet. Shoot dodging to fall behind cover is a tricky afair, one little snag and he aborts his dive making things only worse. Even when you succesfully dive behind a desk or something he still annoyingly exposes himself while getting up and into cover.

Some beautiful locations, interesting story and great monologue which makes looking for 'clues' a lot more interesting then it really is. But the gameplay doesn't hold up imo.

I do not detract it for the aiming faults much because I am sure there are less problems with the default autoaim on. They should patch in things to make it work better without it, but they obviously assumed most people would do the default. I score higher because I think it has a great aesthetic appeal and the multiplayer is fun. I am not really a fan of tps multiplayer only fps so I did not play as long. Still enjoyable. Plus, I think it has a lot more good than bad. The problems I faced we both described were only a major fault in part 3. I am also sure most players will use autoaim and play on normal thus having a much smooher go with the action.

One way or another it reminds me of Kayne & Lynch...

Well I just finished it. I set it to easy with auto-aim in the end, the game play wasn't fun anymore. It all rather fell apart during Act 3. All the control issues were further aggravated by frequently running out of ammo in the last chapter.
Auto aim isn't all that great either, it defaults to stomach height which is usually obstructed by cover. It does make it very easy to take out guys running around in the open though.

I stand by 6.5/10, a good game yet I can't forgive it all the flaws. I have no interest in multiplayer, might replay a chapter or 2, then it's a trade in towards Dragon's dogma.

Finish rushed it in one sitting(Beast gaming session or what :')), finished it on Medium with auto aim off. Overall I can't say I was too impressed, the shooting got boring near the end, and there were sooo many fucking enemies to kill - literally my kill count at the end was probably bordering 2k people. Now think about it, one person taking out 2000 people!? What the fuck? Kind of over the top in terms of lobbing enemies at you. The final bit was even more infuriating (in the hangar).

Possibly a 7.5, lowest score I'd give a Rock* game I think, it was okay, nothing special however, the dialogue and some levels are redeeming from an otherwise considerably lower score.

Also, multiplayer is a pile of trash. Just to throw that in there as well, I enjoyed GTA IV and RDR, this is just.. terribad.