IIRC, nen was never in trouble of a single thing. You think this is bad, look at last round or the one before, where I stopped lynches on townies with not even any evidence to speak of, just a gut feeling. In the end, I was right, and I'm pretty sure I'm right about this too.

Also, this isn't overconfidence. This is confidence. If I was overconfident I'd point out the 5 or 6 players who I think are obvtown. No, for now it's just nen and stefl.

It's part of the game mario. You think police investigators politely ask questions? No. They crack their suspects or witnesses until they get an answer.

For instance, he can't even tell me what's suspicious about it. Sure he can say, "it's a little strange", but that's like 10 seconds of thought going into that one. Most of my actions involve a good 5-10 minutes of deliberation, and sometimes I go days without asking a question.

I've been verbally abusive in the past, but I'm nowhere close to what I was.

LOL You can call me dumb all you want. It hardly changes our situation and what I was trying to convey and what your answer is.

In the previous post you said that you have saved people on "gut feelings" which is possible, but then you in the next post itself say that I haven't put more than 10 secs of thought in my post.

So which is more important, 10 seconds of thought or gut feelings?

Ok, I understand what you are getting at now. I realize you voted after he answered and not during, but when I said "he failed to answer Rol's question" I was trying to say "he answered it, but in the wrong way". I was, and still am suspicious of him, but I'm not sure if it enough to vote for him yet.  Things can change very fast in mafia though.

I guess I am just too nice. lol

You are justified for your suspicion, I was just making a point about name calling.

Well, I have a lot more experience than you, so my gut feelings are probably far more accurate. That being said. ten seconds is NOTHING to brag about.

I want you to think about what you said "defending him seemed suspicious" and I want you to think about it for at least an hour. Not just from the standpoint that I'm mafia, but from all standpoints. I want you to think about that and then come back and tell me exaclty how it is suspicious given the context in which it happened.

My gut is an accumulation of thinking about scenarios like this for hours at the gym, or on the way to work. Questioning why Linkz is saying something is something I often do because he hides a lot of information in his posts. And you have to pull yourself away from thinking "that's scummy" to thinking, "OK, so he said this, who does that benefit and why is he saying it".Just re-read it now, and come back and explain it to me.

I actually thought for more than 10 seconds. It was like 10 minutes. My thoughts revolved around a lot of people.

Who do you think feels suspicious?

Okay, well, radish has indeed stepped up to thte plate with substantial original analysis, and it's fairly convincing too. I had been somewhat suspicious of moreno before, but now I'm willing to vote him. Keep it up, radish. Or else.

I think the NinPie thing will shake out over the next Day or two ... moreno is the better lynch toDay.

moreno is a much better lynch than Rainbow Yoshi as well, because so far it looks like Rainbow Yoshi has no intention of giving this game any serious participation. Either he will start playing for real, in which case there is no need to lynch him, or he will get modkilled or nightkilled or whatever. I think we can do better by lynching moreno, although I'd certainly lynch Yoshi before I No Lynched in light of Yoshi's behavior.

Unvote radishhead
Vote morenoingrato
Vote time limit

And I second the motion to have hatmoza poke him HARD.

My top two for the moment are moreno and baal.

Not saying they are definitely mafia, but more conversation would go a long way.

Tonight I'll analyse a couple more players- but in the meanwhile it's exam day! :p

Vote time limit

It's kinda dumb that we actually have to vote for this sort of thing.