You guys are posting way too fast. I've been skipping a lot of material.
Doing a thorough re-read now while at work, so it'll be every time I have a free moment. Just a couple of thoughts though.

I'm inclined to believe that Baal is mafia. One of his first posts is a variety of the yes/no speculation that I do so dislike. Generally it follows the form of "I'm thinking that X was scummy, But Y, so maybe that means he's town"
I take those kinds of posts as "put attention on this player, but I'm staying out of this".

Also, Rol's questioning him about the cult, Baal replied "I think they would make it difficult for us to find them". This is a classic maneuver for mafia to incite panic and create suspicion on people who likely do not already have any. Mafia also like to believe that there is a cult, because it helps them act more town-like; ie, as long as they can hunt something, they are able to look more like a townie.

Lastly, I believe Hatmoza gave spurge's role to someone else (not me, mind you) and made him an alarmist. It's likely that spurge was a mafia, methinks.

Also I feel pretty good about Rol being town.
Firstly for noticing an edit (how do people ever notice these things???)
And secondly when he was questioning.....Baal? That whole time when he was saying right answer wrong answer...he said "we need mroe people in here".
That kind of voluntary statement says to me that he was trying to find a scum and couldn't find anything and is now looking at the people who haven't shown up yet.

That's about the same thing that crossed my mind reading radish's posts, I thought to myself "How convenient that he didn't read these last posts because they contain everything he's saying right now" but I'm gonna leave him the benefit of the doubt and even remove my vote if he keeps it up (and comes up with something original).

Can a moderator really do that?

Yes, if a early modkill throws off the balance they can do that, anyway, a mod can do what he wants...

Well....thats certainly is an interesting theory.  If true that would explain alot actually.

Just out of interest, what makes you think this?

Edit: Sorry, I didn't realise that 3 people had commented on that statement already :S

Damn you for pointing at Baalz minutes before I did! But at least my reasons are different than yours so my post is still valuable.

I don't like that he used the back and forth between Rol and NintendoPie to vote for NinPie. No matter how badly NP handled the situation, I don't think that alone warrants a vote (much less from someone who claims he doesn't like to vote on Day One), that move from Baalzamon felt to me like Mafia pouncing on an easy prey.

Don't edit posts radish. You wanted to know why Proff thought that.

And all of the people who commented didnt answer that question for you so why forget your question?