I don't think you can say I "rarely" post. I did have to work Friday and Saturday so I wasn't as active those days. Either way, if you counted all the posts each person has so far I think I would be above you.

I'm sorry, but you are purposely twisting what we already know to make your theory work. Luigi is not a female, Tails is not a female, Duke Nukem is not a female, Pac Man is not a female, Master Chief is not a female, Alucard is not a female, Professor Oak is not a female, kiryu (or whatever his name is) is not a female, my characters in not a female, and I'm sure there are others like this as well. That is AT LEAST 9 characters who are not females, yet you still believe in your theory?

This is something I would expect mafia to say. Why are you so curious about his role NintendoPie?

Although really, the weakness of the theory could be considered evidence by itself.  Forgetting Duke Nukem was probably genuine.  Luigi, oh he must have been swapped by the mod.  Tails, well Tails just doesn't count somehow?  Alucard is a miller so there. 

Male characters are mafia even though every flip to date has been male non-mafia.  Mafia are main characters even though the starting flavor has Mario, Sackboy, and Marcus Fenix swinging by their necks.  This is some really half assed shit prof. 

Because he thinks mine was worthless, which it was not.

Unvote prof

This may be uncharacteristically bad of him but if he were mafia executing some grand scheme I would not expect this many holes. He must be phoning it in for some other reason. Temporary insanity?

I am thinking the same thing. His theory isn't perfect and yet he is pursuing trucks for no reason imo. Trucks didn't waste time in declaring his role, character and stuff. It was on day 1 as well so it was not discussed. Why the suspicion on him?

Why the suspicion on nintendopie? He ALSO says he roleblocked trucks (which imo would be extremely dumb) but trucks does say that he got an innocent reading, so if he was blocked he would have got no result or something.

He has also unwittingly accused ninpie of targeting rol. That's impossible. Ninpie came back and told us baalz's character. If he killed Rol for being a "threat" he would have done it through something like vigilante or something. A night action that is not mafia action. Because I doubt ninpie would be in charge of his mafia team.

Unless, both ninpie and Baalz are in a team, which I think is even more improbable. Baalz went flying at ninpie on day 1, and so did Rol. So now Rol is a "threat" and Baalz is not? Baalz was much more vocal in his argument than Rol too.

We are unnecessarily equating X is fighting Y to X is in Y's team. It doesn't have to be that way, especially on day 1 when it's not really required.

You get the names of characters. You don't get alignment (although Yuna is likely to be town, we don't know for sure), or role - it's not "useless", I guess, but for a power-heavy round, it's a bit disappointing

It is useless until we figure out which characters are good and which ones are not. Prof's theory simply can't work, and a lot of these characters are not protagonists in their games, (luigi, Tails, etc.) so we really don't know yet.

Hey prof, why weren't you pushing ninpie to reveal who Yuna was, so we could lynch her for being a main character?

Where is that link to the quick-topic you supposedly made?

Also, after all this it seems like you just wanted to see a list of names so you would know if your fake claim was reasonable or not.

HoS: Prof

Oh good, so he's not just being mean to me.

I'm not gonna lie though, Prof's been pushing pretty darn hard these past few days. It's pretty easy to point a finger of suspicion his way... or even a Pimp Hand of Suspicion!