Please try to convey your thoughts in more than one sentence so we don't have to clog up everything with posts.
This feels like a miscommunication, so in the future, try to explain your thought process completely in order to expedite conversations.

Your "erm" doesn't follow because he says "night abilities". Like I said, it is simply a clarification. He's implying that he's a regular townie with a passive role like "voteless" or "priest" or "actor" etc. In my post he says regular townie. A regular townie doesn't even have passive roles, they are just plain.
Like I said, your quotes are just clarifications where he puts conditions on his original post. "Regular townie" in my post becomes "no night action" in yours, the reference to 'no role' in my post becomes "not a cop or doc role" in yours. Do you see?

I'm reading your "He doesn't know about any other role" again and again as I'm typing this trying to answer you, but I'm not sure what you're trying to say, still.

Hmm...I don't know. I guess I misunderstood you. You say that a regular townie can be voteless/actor/priest? I didn't consider it that way. I thought a regular townie was a like a regular cop with no conditions attached.

whew i am a grumpy mcgumprson today. Diablo 3 and up at 5am do not mix well.

@Stefl

Everyone has their playstyle for Mafia, and while yours (along with Rols and Profs) is serious deducer (which is fine, you're honestly doing a great job), I like to sit back and play my own game. If you could probably tell from my "butcher" persona, I like to have a bit of fun being "that mysterious dude" that people are never quite sure about (other fun persona's to play as: the Mortician, Crazy Bum, etc, ). This is just a game, and I was intending to have some fun with it.

As for day 1 lynchs, I still stand by my opinion of them. And while we did have some interesting discussions about one another that has led to some interesting leads, I still don't think that one day without anything happening (aka a Mafia kill, or even a Vigilante kill) is a reason to kill off anyone during Day 1. There's just not enough solid information bar an outright confirmation. We ended up with a no lynch in the end, so it worked out. And like I said, things get much more clearer and fun once the first night is over with. And here we are, and so it is.

I do apologize if I seem like I'm here to ruin the game. Not my intention at all... but in my defense, I am trying to hold my cards to best support the game. I mean, right now we've got both of our cops out in the open... and we're only on the second day. That's... um... (if I may say so) not very smart Mafia. There's usually a rule in place in live Mafia where one can't come out and reveal their role... so I'm kinda taken aback at how quickly people are just telling others (including Mafia members) who they are. I mean, there's really not a good counter for that (only that the doctor now knows who to protect... but now he has a 50/50 chance of having a successful procedure, and leaves everyone else out to be picked off by Mafia).

For all of our good deductions and clue findings, we're not playing smart Mafia at the moment. And Mafia members have the advantage right now.

Claiming is part of mafia. The point is mafia can claim as well. We dont know for sire of tjeyre telling the trutg.

Thing is, when I posted that I didn't know that everyone had a role. I thought that "abilities" and "roles" were two different things. I didn't think that I had a role, but an ability. I thought that the only townie roles were doc and cop - but now I understand that everyone (I'm asuming anyway) has a role. Why did I seperate the two to begin with? I can't actually DO anything with my role/power. I can't go out at night doing stuff - which I thought was what "roles" did, but I was wrong about that. Every one has a role it would seem - which I wasn't aware of until quite recently. Or rather, I didn't UNDERSTAND that everyone has a role.

Hope you understand what I mean... Or else come back and say so and I'll try to explain in another way.

But what if there's no real cop in this game? I don't remember it right now, but didn't Truck say that he wasn't a real cop? It sounded more like he only had part of the abilities a cop have - just like NinPie says he does. Perhaps they only can see the name of characters, and we have to figure out what team they're on? Do you follow me here, or am I doing a bad job at conveing my thoughts? =P

Would you mind wording that in a different way? I don't know if I quite follow?

We don't know until we find one.  But perhaps that's the way this game works? NinPie isn't a full out cop, he's a flavor cop (I think it's called) and it would seem as if Trucks also a flavor cop (but can't remember at this very moment). Two flavor cops - if both are telling the truth. And if that's the case it would render the godfather useless (well, at the very least cripple him) IF townies have protagonist names and mafias are antagonists....

I see.

I want to know your suspects. Honest suspects that you think are highly suspicious, possible mafias.