I wouldn't play a mafia game if I didn't feel that I had enough time to read every single post.

.....

On another note, I feel most comfortable lynching either HappyDolphin or Basil today. Actually, I would even feel comfortable with a double lynch on both of them. There is no way we should go with a no lynch with all this activity we have to work with. It is obvious to me that both of them messed up, or they simply don't know what they are doing. Being first time players here on VGC, I'm leaning towards both options being true. I'll keep my vote as is for now.

A double lynch?
Is that even possible? If it is, we should do something to avoid it. Possibly losing 2 town members would be a hard hit.
1 town 1 mafia would be not so bad, though. (I don't think both are mafia.)

With that being said, I'm off to bed. I have to work tomorrow and should be back online around 10 pm. I pray that I don't have 700 more posts to come back too.

Goodnight guys.

Double lynches are up to the mod although rarely allowed and I have never seen one. I see very few benefits of them while there are many problems. The biggest one being we get not info on the flip on either before the lynch of the other.

In this game with draws being no lynch. There shouldn't be any double lynches.

I'm going to enter my default Day 1 stance, since I'm not really happy about lynching Trucks today- I think we just had a misunderstanding

Unvote: [anyone that I had a vote on]
Vote: No Lynch

Actually after all the work we put into getting everyone to day 1 lynch (except radish), I do not want to change that - It gives often more information than any later lynch - since you are forcing scum to bind to some decisions, because most scum are afraid to change it.

Long story short:

+1 day 1 lynch

I haven't yet caught up.  In fact I'm still 400 posts behind.  Here's what I've got: 

Thoughts on Pgs. 9-10: 
Prof's theory about Happy exactly mirrors my thoughts ever since his "you'll be sorry!" post.  I almost literally facepalmed.   Happy:  In the future, just try to tough it out unless you think you're in IMMINENT danger of being lynched because what you did makes you a HUUUUGE target for scum, assuming you aren't scum.  (It almost doesn't matter what you really are:  if you're that important, they want you dead.) 

Thoughts on Pg. 11:  radish is starting to look pretty bad, I mean FFS somewhere between 30-80% of the pokemon must be cute, right?  On the other hand this sort of avoidance makes little sense for lying scum IMO and much more sense for stupid panicky townie. 

Pg. 12

Also, right now I would be most inclined to lynch one of the really bad lurkers, just because this game has lots of people and it's not looking like we have any better suspects. If we are inclined as a town to give them a break because they're noobs (I think the bad lurkers are all noobs at this point?) then we can No Lynch I guess.