By using this site, you agree to our Privacy Policy and our Terms of Use. Close

Forums - General Discussion - Mafia Round 40. Pokemon! Gotta Catch them all!

Wonktonodi on 06 May 2012
morenoingrato said:
The insane cop claim has been very effective for Radish if he is Mafia, that means that both times, he protected nen, that could be a possibility and there is no way to counter-prove his claims, even if they are very questionable.

Nen's story is just too perfect, he tracked Radish on Day 2, Mario days on Day 3, he tracked Radish AGAIN on day 3, with no results, that day there were no killings, and he tracked him (AGAIN?) on day 4, saying Radish killed Trucks, and Trucks died.

It just looks too fabricated to me. Assuming Radish was Mafia, he had other people to perform the kills for him, and then when he didn't target anyone no one died? Someone else could have done the kill, but that's not what Nen is suggesting. And day 4 he tracks him again in day 4 and his target dies? Well, that seems more believable since Radish could have been alone then.

Okay, IDK about Wonk, but either Radish or Nen are Mafia, because one of them is making up their claims.

I'm not fully following you.  Nen only listed 2 of the nights he tracked as far as I saw. He said radish to Mario.  and radish to TOS last night.



Around the Network
Wonktonodi on 06 May 2012
morenoingrato said:
Day/Name Radish - Insane Doc nen - watcher
 Nightkills
1 Rol (Saved?)
 -
2 Mario (Killed?) Radish (Mario) Prof
3 Nen (Saved?) Radish (Nothing) Pezus, Rol
4 Nen  (Saved?) Radish (ToS) No Nightkills
5     ToS


I think this is off.

Prof was killed night one. Mario was also killed night 2  There was no night kill night 3 and last night was night 4.



Wonktonodi on 06 May 2012
morenoingrato said:
Day/Name Radish - Insane Doc nen - watcher
 Nightkills
1 Rol (Saved?) Blocked by TOS
Prof
2 Mario (Killed?) Radish (Mario) Pezus, Rol, Mario
3 Nen (Saved?)

Radish (Nothing)

where did nen say this?

 No Nightkills
4 Nen  (Saved?) Radish (ToS)
ToS
5    





Wonktonodi on 06 May 2012
nen-suer said:
Guess its time i role claimed. I'm a tracker
I tracked Radish to Mario that why i wanted him dead, but then he claimed insane doc and Hat had a lead on manuel and the day ended with Moreno's shot.

I tracked Radish again last night, but he didnt leave his home (lied about targeting me)
but then Trucks stole the show after that and we got spurg.

Last night Radish targeted Trucks and since he just said he targeted me, i think there is no way he was telling the truth about his claim.

So what about night 1 and night 3?



Moren on 06 May 2012
Wonktonodi said:
morenoingrato said:
Day/Name Radish - Insane Doc nen - watcher
 Nightkills
1 Rol (Saved?)
 -
2 Mario (Killed?) Radish (Mario) Prof
3 Nen (Saved?) Radish (Nothing) Pezus, Rol
4 Nen  (Saved?) Radish (ToS) No Nightkills
5     ToS


I think this is off.

Prof was killed night one. Mario was also killed night 2  There was no night kill night 3 and last night was night 4.

"I tracked Radish to Mario that why i wanted him dead, but then he claimed insane doc and Hat had a lead on manuel and the day ended with Moreno's shot."

"I tracked Radish again last night, but he didnt leave his home (lied about targeting me)
but then Trucks stole the show after that and we got spurg."

"Last night Radish targeted Trucks and since he just said he targeted me, i think there is no way he was telling the truth about his claim."

 

He is talking about 3 nights here.

Also, about the table, I meant that in that day they woke up dead.



Around the Network
Moren on 06 May 2012
Wonktonodi said:
nen-suer said:
Guess its time i role claimed. I'm a tracker
I tracked Radish to Mario that why i wanted him dead, but then he claimed insane doc and Hat had a lead on manuel and the day ended with Moreno's shot.

I tracked Radish again last night, but he didnt leave his home (lied about targeting me)
but then Trucks stole the show after that and we got spurg.

Last night Radish targeted Trucks and since he just said he targeted me, i think there is no way he was telling the truth about his claim.

So what about night 1 and night 3?

That one is night 3, he said last night, but it was poorly worded.



Wonktonodi on 06 May 2012
morenoingrato said:
Wonktonodi said:
morenoingrato said:
Day/Name Radish - Insane Doc nen - watcher
 Nightkills
1 Rol (Saved?)
 -
2 Mario (Killed?) Radish (Mario) Prof
3 Nen (Saved?) Radish (Nothing) Pezus, Rol
4 Nen  (Saved?) Radish (ToS) No Nightkills
5     ToS


I think this is off.

Prof was killed night one. Mario was also killed night 2  There was no night kill night 3 and last night was night 4.

"I tracked Radish to Mario that why i wanted him dead, but then he claimed insane doc and Hat had a lead on manuel and the day ended with Moreno's shot."

"I tracked Radish again last night, but he didnt leave his home (lied about targeting me)
but then Trucks stole the show after that and we got spurg."

"Last night Radish targeted Trucks and since he just said he targeted me, i think there is no way he was telling the truth about his claim."

 

He is talking about 3 nights here.

Also, about the table, I meant that in that day they woke up dead


talking about 3 nights and 2 of them are last night LOL



Wonktonodi on 06 May 2012
morenoingrato said:
Wonktonodi said:
nen-suer said:
Guess its time i role claimed. I'm a tracker
I tracked Radish to Mario that why i wanted him dead, but then he claimed insane doc and Hat had a lead on manuel and the day ended with Moreno's shot.

I tracked Radish again last night, but he didnt leave his home (lied about targeting me)
but then Trucks stole the show after that and we got spurg.

Last night Radish targeted Trucks and since he just said he targeted me, i think there is no way he was telling the truth about his claim.

So what about night 1 and night 3?

That one is night 3, he said last night, but it was poorly worded.


that would be od targeting radish 3 nights in a row



Moren on 06 May 2012
Wonktonodi said:


that would be od targeting radish 3 nights in a row

Indeed, we need clarification from him, about who he targeted on night one.

If his claim is doubtful, we lynch him and he flips Mafia. And if town doesn't win by then, you are Mafia.

I just know either him or Radish are Mafia, since they are contradicting each other.



Wonktonodi on 06 May 2012
morenoingrato said:
Wonktonodi said:


that would be od targeting radish 3 nights in a row

Indeed, we need clarification from him, about who he targeted on night one.

If his claim is doubtful, we lynch him and he flips Mafia. And if town doesn't win by then, you are Mafia.

I just know either him or Radish are Mafia, since they are contradicting each other.


that plan doesn't work if they both are mafia.