if you had more reasons it's very silly to say one reason was the only reason.

The other reasons weren't sufficient to make me vote hatmoza.  I mean come on, it would be terrible if I voted just to end the day without a good reason to lynch someone.  And, all else being equal, I would have been willing to give hatmoza the benefit of the doubt instead of immediately forcing him to prove his claim.  But the ADDITIONAL fact that Happy just wasn't apparently going to get lynched made testing hatmoza's claim a very reasonable backup plan. 

I "only" voted him once that became clear.  Do you get it now? 

(You can ignore this next part, but I find it interesting and instructive:  "Variation in the placement of only can change the meaning of the sentence, as the following examples show: Dictators respect only force; they are not moved by words. Dictators only respect force; they do not worship it. She picked up the receiver only when he entered, not before. She only picked up the receiver when he entered; she didn't dial the number."  http://www.thefreedictionary.com/only

(I didn't say I lynched hat only because Happy wasn't getting lynched.)

and that brings us full circle back to a bandwagon vote :P

very informative though thanks :)

Sounds plausible.

I also think there are 4 or 5 mafia members. 4 or 5 out of 19 sounds like a good ratio.

Yup, who do you think those 4 or 5 mafia members most likely are? Same question goes to everyone else as well.

and why can't radish be both?

If there are that many, some that look unsuspicious must be scum, so it's really hard to say.
At this point I'm wary of spurge (as mentioned a bit before).
I'm not completely sure of pezus and NintendoPie either.

As for scum ratio, I found this neat calculator:
http://games-net.de/hosted/tggc/trash/mafiacalc.php?mafia=5&town=14&phase=0&votechance=0&do=Go!
With 5 mafia and 14 town, the chance of a town win is apparently 9.20%. I don't like than number. :(

4 to 15 would be a 17.76 % chance of a town win.
http://games-net.de/hosted/tggc/trash/mafiacalc.php?mafia=4&town=15&phase=0&votechance=0&do=Go!

I don't know how reliable those calculations are, but I find them interesting.

When I was looking to see how much you said today so far I remembered this.

You seem a bit too defiant like you cant talk outside the thread and since 2 townie who could do that are already gone that makes you a little more likely to be scum.

Just saying you are townie doesn't mean much. The lie detector isn't a common role and there are many people the lie detector could go for if there was one.

I disagree on it being meaningless. It does a pretty good job of showing people who lurked. Obviously your case is defferent since you put many posts into one, so your post count woudl show a lurker while the content puts you way out of it.

It also can show people who were under a lot of heat. Such as HD and Hat being up there. And that we have some spammers. spurge and pezuz.

Well, you can't necessarily leave the vote chance at 0, some days we will be 100% sure, some days 50% sure, and so on. Leaving it on 0 means it is just a random vote, so the odds will be very low. We have a better chance that what those percentages indicate.