I won't post anymore tonight but rereading the exchange between radish and stelf, I'm not sure if radishhead is scum or just a big bumbling idiot.

Done with Pezus, there are 4 things he said that were not opinions, questions or things that couldn't have been proven as a fact right away, all related to his alignement. Also, looking at the others, I'm sure Pezus is the one who lied, but the one who lied is notnecessarily Mafia.

..........................................................................................

http://gamrconnect.vgchartz.com/post.php?id=4525178

They tell him he is town, and he somehow agrees, if he was lying, he could have been Mafia.

..........................................................................................

http://gamrconnect.vgchartz.com/post.php?id=4529853

This one is the big question mark, here, he says he is not town, meaning that if he was lying about it, he would become town.

..........................................................................................

http://gamrconnect.vgchartz.com/post.php?id=4529892

He now changes to town, meaning that if he lied, he Mafia.

..........................................................................................

http://gamrconnect.vgchartz.com/post.php?id=4530336

Once again, he confirms he is a townie, meaning that if he is the liar, he is Mafia

..........................................................................................

So, let me put it this way, there's a very, very high chance Pezus is the liar, and a 3/4 chance he is Mafia.

Also, I made some minor typos up there, I'm sleepy, good night everyone.

Oh, man, that night was long and then I missed the start of the day, too. :/
And 4 townies dead? WTF? :((

So... hatmoza was killed, but passed the kill on to happydolphin, right? Then I would assume that hatmoza is town, because such a move would be too strong for mafia. (Were there mafia roles with such a power in previous games? Please let me know if anybody remembers.)

I'm a bit suspicious of spurgeonryan now, because of this:

If the power of redirecting a lynch is a town role, then why would he see hatmoza as a threat?

P.S.: Oh, if anybody wonders why I'm not so active, that has personal causes. I've got a big translation job in, plus my son got a cold which he graciously passed on to me. :( Now I've got to work with a splitting headache and a stuffed nose.
But I'll try to follow the thread and chime in from time to time.

I probably wouldn't have done what hat did, but once hatmoza threw his hat (hur hur) in the ring, there was exactly one right play for Linkz and he did the opposite.  (The pun was entirely unintentional, but now that I've spotted it I'm giggling.)

Calling it bandwagoning is gross oversimplification.  Remember, hatmoza was going to kill Happy anyway, so the only difference was that we'd confirm hatmoza's ability, at the cost of using it up.  Also I wanted the day to finally end. 

That isn't to say that I think hatmoza was wrong to do it; it should have worked and it would have solved teh Happy problem. But I doubt it would occur to me.

Yeah, it had occurred to me at the time that if he wasn't the sibling then it looked like a pretty classic case of scum buddying, but then again I wasn't sure if pezus was just the kind of noob who'd decide something and really go 110% into that belief. And to be honest I'd forgotten these thoughts by now, but I remember now.

Chime in when you see this, please, hatmoza. We might have a good lynch already!

Oh, and while I'm at it:

RADISH PLEASE READ THIS. I KNOW YOU DON'T BOTHER READING A LOT OF THE POSTS, BUT READ THIS ONE.

Okay, now that you're hopefully paying attention, the "I didn't know Final-Fan was referring to me about the doctor protection in the post he made immediately after quoting me in disbelief that I would claim power like that" defense is complete bullshit. There are only two choices now: incompetent or scum.

I think you're incompetent; feel free to convince me I'm wrong.

This one is dedicated for Radish and Pezus.

My general thoughts so far...

I'm a bit frustrated with how the first day and night turned out. With so many posts I was sure we would eventually out a mafia. With Basil not wanting to say he was a townie knowing there was a lie detector I was sure he was mafia and then again with no sibling coming forward I was sure Happy was mafia. Alas, both cases turn out false and that huge first day meant nothing. (At least we have a lot to look back on) We would have been better with a no lynch in the end, after all.  Hindsight is 20/20 though... Still, with only one night kill this most likely means we only have 1 mafia family. (Most likely containing 5 members)

My general thoughts on everyone left...

People I think are mafia: Stefl, Spurge, Pezus, Radish, and Nen. (Most likely to least likely)

People I think are pro town: Hatmoza, Trucks, Moren, Rol, Wonk, Manuel, and Final Fan. (Most likely to least likely)

People I am not sure about: Mugen, NintendoPie (Both are new players, thus making it hard for me to get a read from them)

Comments/ questions on some of the posts made so far...

I would like to hear from you on your suspects. Try to list 5 please, because I am pretty confident there are around 5 mafia in the game.

Agreed. All Linkz had to do was come forward and the doctor could have protected one of them, thus the mafia would have targeted someone else to avoid not getting a kill. Sure, if they got it right they would have gotten two kills, but mafia would not have taken that chance. I'm not sure why, but Linkz seems to always be playing against the town. (At least in the last two games I played with him)

Maybe because it could contain very important information like the player list and other important details. lol

Interesting that you wanted him to "name claim", but he has a lot of Pokemon to chose from as long as no one else is that said Pokemon. I guess him claiming Jigglypuff is legit since he/ she is one of the more popular ones. If someone was going to fake claim they would go with a less popular one, I would think. If anyone else happens to be Jiggly they should say so.

Great job making this table! I don't know if I could have the patience to do something like this with so many posts in this thread. That being said, the table is meaningless.

I wouldn't say I have been lurking. If I made a bunch of small posts like everyone else instead of a few large ones would that make you happier? If I do start doing that then I would be spamming, no? I'll stick to my usual methods.