By using this site, you agree to our Privacy Policy and our Terms of Use. Close

Forums - General - Mafia Round 40. Pokemon! Gotta Catch them all!

Mario, prof and rol were the only player who I believe showed sheer concern for the town losing two siblings by reminding HD and the sibling of the consequences if they didn't come forward. My scum list until we get a lead or notice any contradictions from day 1:

Wonk -for not sharing that great of concern with siblings, in my eyes at least. Rather he joined the barbed Linkz in wasting some of their posts in taunting rather than calculating the seriousness of my approach for finding out if HD was really town without killing/lynching him.

Nooewbs - MUGEN, ninpie manuel and Pezus (if this is his first game) since my PM alludes to a lying sack of shit newb. (ironically, no one's even asked about it ???)


Anyone I didn't list are players I haven't look into yet.



I am the black sheep     "of course I'm crazy, but that doesn't mean I'm wrong."-Robert Anton Wilson

Around the Network
spurgeonryan said:
Wonktonodi said:


I still don't know how he got lynched fisrt 2 days in a row yet radish seems to never get lynched day one.

Possibly because radish does not give up until the last day, Morenoingrato usually gives up day one. When he is town.

 

I swear Radish was on right now.

 

@ Radish

 

If you are on go ahead and come in and vote no lynch again and time limit so that you can have some more fun with us tonight.

 

HoS Radish because of Day one and he always just sits back and pushes for the end.


I have read this several times and I will try not to be mean as hat, but this post has caused some brain damage.



hatmoza said:


Nooewbs - MUGEN, ninpie manuel and Pezus (if this is his first game) since my PM alludes to a lying sack of shit newb. (ironically, no one's even asked about it ???)


Come again?



Signature goes here!

RolStoppable said:
Wonktonodi said:

Two other theories that are not too complex would be two night kills targeting prof, or one being role blocked.

You could then get into more complex theories like prof watching a paranoid gun owner.

I suppose Night 1 really doesn't give us any good hint then.

And Day 1... I don't know. Our two main suspects (HD and hat) both turned out to tell the truth, so the question is who behaved strangly?

moreno didn't want to let HD get away and pezus showed the opposite by defending HD. But since hatmoza was on HD's case as well and it turned out he told us the truth about his "trick room" move, it makes me wonder why pezus was apparently convinced of HD's innocence when nobody else wasn't.

If we had a scum flip somewhere, we could easily make connections with players and the flipped scum based on the discussions of day 1. Even though town flips still help, they don't help as much as scum flips.

Strongest leads imo in order of strength: Investigation/scan, scum flip, general flip.

 

Right now, you're doing it right, which is why I have you pinned as town, but I've been fooled before.



I am the black sheep     "of course I'm crazy, but that doesn't mean I'm wrong."-Robert Anton Wilson

hatmoza said:
Mario, prof and rol were the only player who I believe showed sheer concern for the town losing two siblings by reminding HD and the sibling of the consequences if they didn't come forward. My scum list until we get a lead or notice any contradictions from day 1:

Wonk -for not sharing that great of concern with siblings, in my eyes at least. Rather he joined the barbed Linkz in wasting some of their posts in taunting rather than calculating the seriousness of my approach for finding out if HD was really town without killing/lynching him.

Nooewbs - MUGEN, ninpie manuel and Pezus (if this is his first game) since my PM alludes to a lying sack of shit newb. (ironically, no one's even asked about it ???)


Anyone I didn't list are players I haven't look into yet.

you bluff in this game so much don't blame me that linkz didn't believe you.

I didn't want you to go after him day one. I still think you should have given him a night. I know I'm not the only one to feel that way, or you wouldn't have been "lynched" day one.

If you weren't pretty much confirmed town I'd try and get the town to lynch you again on principle. your appoach was terrible.



Around the Network
spurgeonryan said:
Whatever.

I am sick of you guys treating all my ideas like they are crap. If I notice something that seems relevant I will post it.

Now I have to deal with you and Rol being jerks to me.

Maybe something I notice mean something and maybe I am just seeing things. Either way it adds to the thread. If is stupid just look over it. At least you will know that that is not something you have to worry about. If it makes sense then Great! That is something you can think about.

Please don't turn into HappyDolphin.

Your previous post was very unclear "HoS Radish because of Day one and he always just sits back and pushes for the end." What part of his Day One actions didn't you like? What do you mean by he always sits back and pushes for the end? Did you think he pushed for the end of Day One too soon? Are you talking about his general behavior in games?



Signature goes here!

Wonktonodi said:
hatmoza said:
Mario, prof and rol were the only player who I believe showed sheer concern for the town losing two siblings by reminding HD and the sibling of the consequences if they didn't come forward. My scum list until we get a lead or notice any contradictions from day 1:

Wonk -for not sharing that great of concern with siblings, in my eyes at least. Rather he joined the barbed Linkz in wasting some of their posts in taunting rather than calculating the seriousness of my approach for finding out if HD was really town without killing/lynching him.

Nooewbs - MUGEN, ninpie manuel and Pezus (if this is his first game) since my PM alludes to a lying sack of shit newb. (ironically, no one's even asked about it ???)


Anyone I didn't list are players I haven't look into yet.

you bluff in this game so much don't blame me that linkz didn't believe you.

I didn't want you to go after him day one. I still think you should have given him a night. I know I'm not the only one to feel that way, or you wouldn't have been "lynched" day one.

If you weren't pretty much confirmed town I'd try and get the town to lynch you again on principle. your appoach was terrible.


You underestimate my ability to gain town trust over and over again. You don't think I already had it calculated that I would get lynched? Cry me a fucking river because your "shit play" tactics against me ain't worth a squirt of piss, especially after Linkz display of butthurtness ... and it burns you to know I'm guaranteed town and that the cards are in my hands.

So tell me, now that you can't pull a lynch train on me, who would you want to lynch and why?



I am the black sheep     "of course I'm crazy, but that doesn't mean I'm wrong."-Robert Anton Wilson

spurgeonryan said:
Yes I am talking about his general behavior in games. He seems to push for a no lynch and time limit, then ends up being scum at the end after he just went on a 1-3 day murder spree.

Also to make sure that I did not make a mistake I went through to find Radish's mistake just now. I swear this guy has only post maybe a dozen times or less. Crazy Quiet! Seems like he has post less than you trucks.

He just pushes on with I will make a full reveal in a few days. Yet another stalling maneuver.

I like his " You got to believe I am town " Speech. That is not exactly as he said just off memory from a page or so ago.

Long story short since I cannot find it. I believe he was caught in a lie, and did not have anywhere near a good reason for it. I think it was final fan. Put all that together and you have a

HoS Radish.

Now that was a good post! Apart for the fact that you attribute my work to Final-Fan.



Signature goes here!

 

Further on scum hunting by re-observing day one:

Incident - Trucks on cute Pokemon

What we now know is true - human characters capture pokemon =  anti factions killing town

i.e humans are bad, pokeon are town. As many already suggested in day 1

 

The quotes for town who genuinely answered as if they were pokemon:

theprof00 said:
Oooh, my pokemon is a cutey-patootie. Meow-row
NintendoPie said:

>_ <
I guess my Pokemon is what you guys view me as........
Anyway... reporting in!
*What did I get myself into?!*

 

the quotes for scum who fell for Trucks question:

radishhead said:
Since when are cute pokemon scummy? D:

Actually- if prof is hinting at what I think he's hinting at, it's a bit of a strange pokemon to align to the town side of the game
Stefl1504 said:
I don't even know my pokemon from its name - must be one of those unfun new gen pokemon T.T

I put stefl here because it seems like he's playing it safe.

 

People who ignored the question the question but posted before I pointed out trucks trap:

Pezus

Rol



I am the black sheep     "of course I'm crazy, but that doesn't mean I'm wrong."-Robert Anton Wilson

What I didn't like about Radish is him voting for someone as soon as they mentioned him.