By using this site, you agree to our Privacy Policy and our Terms of Use. Close

Forums - Gaming Discussion - Top Game Developer of all Time, (Irrational is the winner!!) - ....VG Chartz user's are f***ed (me included)

DepthAlly on 29 April 2012
MrT-Tar said:

+ Monolith

- Rockstar


We posted close to each other so you'll need to edit a bit.



Food for thought: Shove an apple in your brain

Around the Network
sales2099 on 29 April 2012
pezus said:
sales2099 said:
pezus said:
sales2099 said:
I noticed that Turn 10 isnt there.

Making a game every 2-2.5 years with not a single game below 90 on metacritic. I defy any other dev you listed to be just as qualified.

While Forza isnt my favourite franchise in gaming...I at least think the dev who makes it is the best in the industry.

While I do agree that they should have been there, I am not at all surprised by the bolded.

What does that mean? This isnt fanboyism on my part here. And this has nothing to do with how much people like or dislike Forza. 

No other dev in the industry can crank out ONLY 90+ metacritic games on a biannual basis. None. 

Wrong

Oh now isnt that a nice surprise. 

Funny I dont see Blizzard on this thread either. 



Xbox: Best hardware, Game Pass best value, best BC, more 1st party genres and multiplayer titles. 

 

ruimartiniman on 29 April 2012

Platinum Games 42
Rockstar 35
Maxis 35
Dice 56
Visceral Games 57
Shin'en 25
Atlus 16
Ensemble Studios 55
Codemasters 36
LucasArts/LucasFilms 23
Microprose 35
Origin Systems 49
Irrational 46
Treasure 56
Monolith Soft 63
Eidos Montreal 38
Gust 43
Grasshopper Manufacture 15
From Software 29

+ Rockstar

- Atlus





Conegamer on 29 April 2012
Platinum Games 42
Rockstar 35
Maxis 35
Dice 56
Visceral Games 54
Shin'en 25
Atlus 13
Ensemble Studios 55
Codemasters 36
LucasArts/LucasFilms 23
Microprose 35
Origin Systems 49
Irrational 46
Treasure 56
Monolith Soft 65
Eidos Montreal 38
Gust 43
Grasshopper Manufacture 15
From Software 29

+Monolith

-Visceral

 

Also updated with Mr T-Tar's vote from earlier. Don't think it ever went through as the two were so close to each other.



 

Here lies the dearly departed Nintendomination Thread.

IIIIITHE1IIIII on 29 April 2012

So... One second Dice and Visceral are part of the few great devs left and the next second you downvote them??? :S

Platinum Games 42
Rockstar 35
Maxis 35
Dice 56
Visceral Games 55
Shin'en 25
Atlus 13
Ensemble Studios 55
Codemasters 36
LucasArts/LucasFilms 23
Microprose 35
Origin Systems 49
Irrational 46
Treasure 56
Monolith Soft 65
Eidos Montreal 38
Gust 43
Grasshopper Manufacture 12
From Software 29

+ Visceral Games

- Grasshopper Manufacture



Around the Network
Conegamer on 29 April 2012
IIIIITHE1IIIII said:

So... One second Dice and Visceral are part of the few great devs left and the next second you downvote them??? :S

They have too many points. They're amongst the best, but not the best. Thus, they need some of their points removed.

Odd reasoning, I know. But it clumps everything together, which is where they belong.



 

Here lies the dearly departed Nintendomination Thread.

Aj_habfan on 29 April 2012

Damn this game will never end

Platinum Games 42
Rockstar 35
Maxis 35
Dice 56
Visceral Games 55
Shin'en 25
Atlus 13
Ensemble Studios 55
Codemasters 37
LucasArts/LucasFilms 23
Microprose 35
Origin Systems 49
Irrational 46
Treasure 56
Monolith Soft 65
Eidos Montreal 38
Gust 43
Grasshopper Manufacture 9
From Software 29

+ Codemasters

- Grasshopper

Let's knock a few useless devs off before getting rid of Monolith.



Conegamer on 29 April 2012

pezus said:

 Isn't Monolith almost an exclusively RPG making dev? GTAIV may have been overrated but it is certainly one of the best (the best IMO) open world games of the generation. Besides, GTAIV being overrated is not their fault, it's still easily a 90+ game either way. GTA3, Vice City, San Andreas, IV, RDR and soon Max Payne 3...you can't deny their greatness! But, if you'd like to drop Rockstar off the list please consider the games From Software have made.

 

Yes, but I like their games. 

Also, Rockstar is probably...5th favourite on that list. Grasshopper, Eidos, Platinum, Atlus, Shin'en, and others, are far worse devs.

But Rockstar and Monolith are very, VERY good at what they do. Neither deserve to go. You know that. So stop downvoting them.



 

Here lies the dearly departed Nintendomination Thread.

DepthAlly on 29 April 2012
Platinum Games 42
Rockstar 35
Maxis 35
Dice 56
Visceral Games 55
Shin'en 22
Atlus 13
Ensemble Studios 55
Codemasters 37
LucasArts/LucasFilms 23
Microprose 35
Origin Systems 49
Irrational 46
Treasure 56
Monolith Soft 63
Eidos Montreal 38
Gust 43
Grasshopper Manufacture 9
From Software 30

+ Monolith Soft

- Shin'en



Food for thought: Shove an apple in your brain

MrT-Tar on 29 April 2012
Platinum Games 42
Rockstar 32
Maxis 35
Dice 56
Visceral Games 55
Shin'en 22
Atlus 13
Ensemble Studios 55
Codemasters 37
LucasArts/LucasFilms 23
Microprose 35
Origin Systems 49
Irrational 46
Treasure 56
Monolith Soft 64
Eidos Montreal 38
Gust 43
Grasshopper Manufacture 9
From Software 30

+ Monolith

- Rockstar