RolStoppable said:
noctis placed his vote on radish and kept it there the entire time. Since I suspect both of them to be mafia, it would be a typical move of the mafia on the first Day.
|
I thought this was your first Mafia game?
theprof00 said:
Wow i at least expected an argument...something!
But im not sirprised.. what im most surprised about is that nobody really defended him... |
Assuming we're speaking of moreno, wouldn't you say radish and noctis kind of did?
spurgeonryan said:
I assure you that if theProf was talking to me through some sort of Mafia link I would not be posting like a ass. |
I believe this is the second time someone mentioned mafia being able to talk privately during the Day. Is this new?
TruckOSaurus said:
theprof00 said:
Trucks, by the way, you were not asleep last night. |
I most certainly was.
|
theprof00 said:
So you had an item and didnt use it? |
TruckOSaurus said:
My item was useless.
|
TruckOSaurus said:
I discarded it. |
TruckOSaurus said:
theprof00 said:
Yup its dawn. Ehy domt you have an item?
|
Look outside the sun is way up in the sky! It's not dawn anymore. I discarded my item during Day Two which means I'll get something at twilight.
|
TruckOSaurus said:
I guess there's no harm is spelling it out:
- I didn't have an item to start with, I found it at twilight.
- I didn't do a thing at night.
- I discarded my item today. |
This exchange is logically consistent with everything we know so far. I am struck though by how Truck's answers seem to be baiting prof. I imagine most people would respond to "So you had an item and didn't use it?" with "I didn't have an item at the time" or something that makes it clear that he did not possess an item last night. Instead we got "my item was useless." That seems deliberately misguiding at best.
theprof00 said:
Well i know for a fact that rol didnt make the kill.
Why? Because someone picked up ffs item and rol alteady had one. |
The rules make it possible for a person to use an item at night and still pick one up come dawn. I should think it's equally possible to do a night action (i.e. kill) and still pick up something later. Or am I misunderstanding you?
Alright folks, 'fess up. Who pissed in Linkz' Wheaties this morning?
spurgeonryan said:
I have heard all that I have to hear.
Unvote: Xxain
Vote: theProf
He is too smart to get confused over this item thing. I am not the only one that suspects him either I do not think. Maybe this one time he has slipped up? Just one vote so nothing serious so far, so it is not like this will hurt you too much, unless others agree with me. |
If you're convinced you've found a scum, you keep pushing for information or for votes. You don't go all passive-aggressive, and hope others swoop in and do your thinking for you.
NoCtiS_NoX said:
RolStoppable said:
Let's go back to the beginning.
http://gamrconnect.vgchartz.com/post.php?id=4499068
I accused you of being mafia which you countered by saying that you wanted to help moreno. Only you couldn't, because I casted the hammer vote. The post you "intended" to reply to was this:
http://gamrconnect.vgchartz.com/post.php?id=4497622
It was posted approximately one hour before time ran out. You were online the entire time which you didn't deny in subsequent posts. Yet you are telling us that you couldn't respond to prof's post anymore, because I had already hammered moreno. This means your time window to help moreno was ten (!) minutes. Ten minutes during which you would have to respond to a lengthy post, hope that others read it and be persuaded immediately, because your own vote was irrelevant at this point (radish or no lynch wouldn't have made a difference, so you needed to convince other people to save moreno).
That isn't realistically possible within a timespan of only ten minutes and that's why your entire story falls apart. Your statement that you wanted to help moreno is an outright lie.
|
So this one doesn't illustrate to helping then. http://gamrconnect.vgchartz.com/post.php?id=4497577
Ok I am out.
|
That's not much of a defense in and of itself, but even if it was you were directly responded to by prof, who laid out his case against moreno. So clearly, he was still interested in discussing this. Why did you not accept this invitation, especially since convincing any combination of him, moreno, and/or Rol to vote for anyone or anything else would have avoided the lynch?
RolStoppable said:
We need noname in here. The voice of reason.
Or evil, if he is indeed the head of the mafia. |
'Fraid I'm not going to be much help right now. Going through today's posts brought up three suspects, but there's nothing I can really pin on anyone. I'll re-review, of course, but right now I'm not prepared to vote anyone.
