So MDJ was a town tracker, if we believe wonk's deputy claim, that means there are 3 investigative roles. I would think that would be too much, right?

edit

You're asking the wrong question. A Vig might shoot completely inactive players to reduce the number of absolute question marks, which is exactly why scum is unlikely to do that.

It's more likely that Trucks was killed because he replaced in and for several reasons:

1) As prof's introduction(lawls again) stated, he's a good player.

2) MDJ made no posts to look back on and see if there's a reason he was killed. Likewise, there was very little heat directed towards MDJ. Combined it makes it a "safe" kill without a trail.

3) I was going to try very hard not to meta it, but MDJ being replaced and not moreno made me think that MDJ was either scum or town power. I don't know if anyone else will chime in and openly agree with me here, but if anyone on the scumteam had that thought too then Trucks was a dead man just based on that.

On the plus side, moreno not getting replaced probably makes him a plain townie. Missing his vote is still detrimental, but without claimed damning evidence against him there's no reason to lynch him.

For now MG, I'm just going to say I'm liking you as town. I still think you were wrong about radish yesterday though, and would be happy to discuss that if you want.

That's at least one town power gone to waste on a lurker.
I don't think we should let MDJ sign up any more after this since he doesn't participate much if at all even when he has a role other than vanilla townie.

Mine only kicks in if the cop dies and even then I don't get the cops results.  So not 3 investigators at once even then we don't know much else from the rest of the set up other than that 3 people so far have been vanilla townies.

The answer being fairly obvious merits little explination but since I have little else to post.

We just lost an investigative role who probably never even used his role. So a waste and not helpful to town. I hoped something like this wouldn't happen with the cop. I still hope that. There have been 3 nights to investigate now, he should have something for us to go on. IF he is lurking or nor even participating then it's a waste of a role and hurting the town.

With the role I have I know there is a cop out there. Thats why I could say that with confidence and not wonder if we even have one.

I expect mistakes but I also expect him to come up with something useful. Considering you though him town last game based on the way he was acting I think you may need to toss out your town tells for radish. Or expect him to stab you in the night some more :P