@ spurge
We shouldn't be talking about the mafia topic outside of this thread regardless of the situation. I don't want to break the rules so I will be posting here. If you feel you did not break any rules just ask Stefl.

Anyway, I never insulted you, I didn't attack what you were doing here in VGC, I never called you a spammer so stop putting words in my mouth. If you feel I attack you personally that was not my intention.That's why my qoute to you in started with a question. If you think my sorry was not an apology then I am sorry because English is not my native language.

You two (noc and spurge) can stop with the apologies.
Mafia exists outside the forum rules for a reason: Insults and lies have their place within the game.
The reason is that everything has a purpose.
The only rules you need to follow, which you didn't, is that you talked a bit outside the game. But that's OK because you guys are NOOBS! :D
Don't worry too much about hurt feelings.

The rules of mafia could be taken in a similar way to forum rules.
We are all moderators trying to ban the trolls. (I'd say we're a bit better at it :D)
We "vote out" the people (trolls) who look like they're trying to get rid of others. Sometimes this results in both the troll and the victim getting voted out, but the victim always has the chance that all the trolls are voted out, giving him a kind of victory.

Back on topic, although I do not care about what happened outside the thread, or who is to blame, I would like to know the whole story. Like, who said what, in what order, etc etc.

We have a winner......

BTW for those curious my name is Shu. 

So prof,

I am starting to think it may be a good idea to let it be known who your sibling is.  Considering that the list of possibles seems to be shrunken down to a considerable size.  

radishhead
Baalzamon
NoCtiS_NoX
spurgeonryan

One more person removed from that list would greatly increase the chances at which we hit mafia today.  Now this is of course assuming that everyone that has claimed is telling the truth.  And we believe that Wonk was investigated and came back innocent 

@linkz
how did you deduce that spurge had simply only one shot and wasn't lying about his role completely?
I'll say it is logical, but even a one shot would fulfill the criteria involving the game ending day 2.
Furthermore, I am able to protect or be protected during the day. If a doc also has a day protect variation, then it's odd that it would be to protect from a day vig kill and nothing else.
Of course all you have is my word, but like I said, I have to trade my night protect for a day protect and I just don't see the feasability of that given a day-vig, rather than some other daytime killing role.
Also, just FYI, I cannot protect against lynches. (regarding vette's claim)
It is also interesting and perturbing as well, that he saved me by extending the time, but could have easily used his power, which makes me think there is more at play here than what he says.
A one-shot lynch switcheroo does make some sense to me as a mafia role, but then why not use it on moreno?

I think everyone is doing fine. If I see some momentum, I'll be sure to break it up.

The momentum is going to come to me, since people want me to validate my claim.  I just may or may not choose to switch it to radish,  those other 3 are as good of choices to me as radish is.   Especially spurgeonryan with the recent lying about his role popping up.   

I like noc for a lynch, or radish tbh.

fyi if me or my sibling dies today or tonight, it will be lylo tomorrow given 3 total mafia.

actually, I like spurge and noc best.