By using this site, you agree to our Privacy Policy and our Terms of Use. Close

Forums - General Discussion - Mafia Round 36 - Suikoden II

spurgeonryan said:
Very interesting questions!

Which questions are interesting?



Around the Network
Linkzmax said:
Vetteman94 said:
Linkzmax said:
Oh and in case it's not clear, I do not believe we have a 2-shot vig, whatever Vette is hinting at, and two town siblings. Spurge shoots a sibling day/night one, Vette gets lynched and takes out a townie or whatever, and then the night kill would mean 3-man mafia wins before day two even starts. There's a liar in the claims.

You think there is still 3 mafia left? 

I dont like the vigilante claims either but it fits,  and the last thing we need is a vigilante without any direction,  just blindly firing.  Last game the vigilante took out 2 mafia players,  because he paid attention and looked for the right signs.

Im not lying about my claim and will do a full claim if need be.

Vig shot day one and mafia lynch means game is over before night one. Either way I don't think it fits.

Why do you say the claim fits? I like the modesty though ;)

I wouldn't mind a full claim because as it is I'm not getting it.

Werent you the one complaining about me not paying attention?

There is one mafia dead already,  so at most only 2 still exist



I think you need to reread my posts, I haven't even mentioned today. I'm saying the roles are no good for either 2 or 3 mafia.



Here I'll spell it out:
Day one: 8 townies, 3 mafia
Spurge kills prof or sibling: 6 townies, 3 mafia
Vette lynched and takes out a townie: 4 townies, 3 mafia
Night one: townie killed, mafia wins if 50% is win condition

Day one: 10 townies, 2 mafia
Spurge kills mafia and mafia is lynched, town wins

Now why did you say the vig claim fits?



Linkzmax said:
Here I'll spell it out:
Day one: 8 townies, 3 mafia
Spurge kills prof or sibling: 6 townies, 3 mafia
Vette lynched and takes out a townie: 4 townies, 3 mafia
Night one: townie killed, mafia wins if 50% is win condition

Day one: 10 townies, 2 mafia
Spurge kills mafia and mafia is lynched, town wins

Now why did you say the vig claim fits?


OK well let me help you out with something.  For starters in the sign up thread, Stefl even mentions the possibility of a 2 day game.

And secondly,  I wont be getting lynched.  No matter how hard you guys try to, it wont happen.  I can only die by night kills, or a day time vigilante not knowing what he is doing.



Around the Network

1 is still less than 2 right?



So you're merely unlynchable and the day ends if you reach hammer?



Linkzmax said:
1 is still less than 2 right?

No because your scenarios wont work the way you have them listed.  




Well I can certainly be wrong about your role, but how can you know the 2 mafia scenario is wron?



Linkzmax said:
So you're merely unlynchable and the day ends if you reach hammer?

Technically yes,  but someone will be dying,  its just not me..