By using this site, you agree to our Privacy Policy and our Terms of Use. Close

Forums - General Discussion - Mafia Round 36 - Suikoden II

Final-Fan said:
At this point I'd rather lynch prof than spurge, but I wouldn't mind lynching a lurker like noctis or moreno.

I'm town. Why do you want to lynch me? Give me a chance to convince you otherwise.



Around the Network
spurgeonryan said:
theprof00 said:
Well my gut was right about MG, shouldn't have let you guys make me second guess my thoughts.
MG I thought was town because he contributed to saving me from death in the closing hour.
Thankfully, him being a suspect is no longer an option.

My suspects are moreno, noc, wonk, radish.

The people I'm pretty confident are town are FF, Vette, and of course myself.

I'm on the fence with Linkz, Baal, and spurge.


And I am on the fence with Baalz and linkz. So where does that leave us?

I'd rather vote suspects than people on the fence.

moreno, noc, wonk, radish...I have no problem with any of them, though a bit more on the fence-y with radish.



theprof00 said:
spurgeonryan said:
theprof00 said:
Well my gut was right about MG, shouldn't have let you guys make me second guess my thoughts.
MG I thought was town because he contributed to saving me from death in the closing hour.
Thankfully, him being a suspect is no longer an option.

My suspects are moreno, noc, wonk, radish.

The people I'm pretty confident are town are FF, Vette, and of course myself.

I'm on the fence with Linkz, Baal, and spurge.


And I am on the fence with Baalz and linkz. So where does that leave us?

I'd rather vote suspects than people on the fence.

moreno, noc, wonk, radish...I have no problem with any of them, though a bit more on the fence-y with radish.

and your current vote is?



  l-5 l-4 l-3 l-2 l-1 lynch
Radish vette          
Baalz noctis          
spurge baalz
 prof        
Noctis spurge          
prof Final-Fan          

Radish: vette, ((prof))
Baalz: noctis
Spurge: ((linkz)), baalz, prof
Noctis: spurge
prof: Final-Fan

with 10 players left there are still 6 votes to lynch



unvote
vote noc



Around the Network

So shouldn't he have forced Linkz to nameclaim first?



Money can't buy happiness. Just video games, which make me happy.

Vote: Prof

even he can't keep up with his change in suspects list



Ok since I have to read a lot of post here and I also have to read a lot of post on VGA thread first and all I can say is "Last of Us is freaking awesome". Sorry, I am very hype at that game right now. XD

on topic:

1st of @spurge why the sudden vote for me when linkz voted for you? I think I owe an explanation at that sudden vote.

2nd what the fuck is happening? I am really confused right now first of the sudden flavor and now MG being disabled? I think I need to study Mafiascum again. It looks like this a complicated Mafia round. >_>

3rd I am hoping I will get a response from Baalz to even defend himself but sadly he didn't even respond to me. I feel he is dodging me for some reason or just plain ignoring me so I think I might Vote for NiV for Baalz or between my two choices I have said before.



@Noctis: I was reluctant to discuss NIV because I don't think it is a good idea, and I still don't think it is a good idea. All it will do is mess with the flow of the game if we have all sorts of roles who "know" who will be targeted in a given night. Why did I finally just give in? Because I don't feel like explaining myself 8 million times to people questioning me over and over about why I don't want to talk about it.

And that isn't completely what Wonk pointed out. He went on to point out it becomes a WIFOM situation, which means it isn't a good or bad idea for them to target those who suspect them. I do agree with him on this matter. Who we list as top suspects is, in all reality, irrelevant towards being able to make any conclusions about what the mafia will do.

Finally, I've been talking in absolute? I don't know a damned thing about what is going on. I just can't stand it when people come up with these absolutely crazy ideas of what is going on. This does absolutely nothing to progress the town any further towards lynching a mafia candidate. Sometimes I feel like it might even move town backwards, because they begin discussing alien like situations that are just completely out of wack.

I don't think I have seen a single time where the crazy discussion from early game winds up being remotely close to what actually was happening in the game.



Money can't buy happiness. Just video games, which make me happy.

EBWOP: These crazy alien like discussions drive us away from discussion I feel could be more relevant towards the game. Maybe I misinterpret the point of this discussion, and it is designed to try to get somebody to slip, though. I honestly don't know.



Money can't buy happiness. Just video games, which make me happy.