By using this site, you agree to our Privacy Policy and our Terms of Use. Close

Forums - General Discussion - Mafia Round 36 - Suikoden II

I don't understand how you all can be so bullheaded. This is mafia. That flavor did NOT confirm Linkz as a townie.



Money can't buy happiness. Just video games, which make me happy.

Around the Network
Baalzamon said:
I don't understand how you all can be so bullheaded. This is mafia. That flavor did NOT confirm Linkz as a townie.


I don't know why you come in every now and then insult everyone at once and don't give reasons for your conclusions.



Look linkz. Say mafia can recruit one specific person.
One mafia can use a power during day OR night to out a persons name.
Per usual, mafia can forgo their night kill to try and recruit that person.
say they found their person last night and recruited.
Secondly we dont know what happens during the day. Perhaps using a role during the fay results
in flavor.



I do feel we should move away from Linkz and towards somebody else, however. We have Linkz claiming watcher, and then a flavor that comes out in Linkz favor (as just mentioned, it doesn't completely clear him...but it still must have helped people have a better opinion on him). He isn't the one we should be spending all of our time on now.

I still am just not so sure about Wonk. Given what people have revealed, he should have been the one investigated last night (assuming nobody lied). I would think if he was found guilty that somebody would have been pushing hard for his lynch. So I'm not really confident in going after him today either.

Spurge has been acting awkward the whole entire game. We can't do no lynch two days in a row, and I really don't have anybody else for suspects at the moment.

Vote: Spurge



Money can't buy happiness. Just video games, which make me happy.

@ wonk
Linkz is claiming that the flavor cleared him.
You say baal has no reason for questioning it? Well where is the reasoning behind the flavor clearing him.
sorry but the only 100% clearings imo are made by a cop, with his own flip confirming that hes not paranoid. Everyone else is just varying levels of certainty, and you specifically should not be treating linkz as cleared like that.

You two. Id like everyone to take a look at your affiliation with each other. You vote together. Defend each other. Believe each other 100%.
HoS both of you.



Around the Network

I agree. In fact given that whole thing i just said about someone looking for another, spurge's comments are starting to make sense for mafia or potential mafia.
unvote
Vote spurge



Wonktonodi said:
Baalzamon said:
I don't understand how you all can be so bullheaded. This is mafia. That flavor did NOT confirm Linkz as a townie.

I don't know why you come in every now and then insult everyone at once and don't give reasons for your conclusions.

Conclusions?  Nobody is confirmed anything.  Call it a conclusion if you wish, but I start with this attitude in a game of mafia, and still have it.  A conclusion is others acting as if Linkz is a confirmed townie, when he isn't.  Nobody has provided definitive proof in this game to show that Linkz is in fact a townie, yet people are acting as if it is just magically there.



Money can't buy happiness. Just video games, which make me happy.

theprof00 said:
Linkzmax said:

What would you consider the Friendly Neighbor to be?

I'm in no way saying my role works similarly. Mine is far more useful if used well, but the basic premise of FN is the worst-case for a self-watcher.

How? That basically assumes that mafia have no roles.

I'm genuinely curious about self-watcher. I don't think I've ever played with one. Forgive my ignorance.

Now again, is the role that outed your name a town role? Doesn't initially seem like one.

Worst-case the FN outs himself early, but is confirmed by the visitee. Could be faked by anti-town partners, but is risky if there actually is an FN or because a Tracker or Watcher could infirm the claim. Self-Watcher can confirm themselves by claiming someone else visited them. Once again could be faked, but Tracker or Watcher could infirm the claim. Mayor is another role that I'd lump into confirmable roles. The mayor ability itself could be quite useful if saved until lylo and used to stop a quicklynch, but at the very least he can confirm himself by stopping any lynch. Confirmable roles are nearly always town roles,(and the only exception I've seen in reading games elsewhere was obviously mafia due to the flavor) and are generally meant to give town a boost balance-wise.

Since I've only played here I've never had this role nor played with it either, but had I not claimed I may have been able to nab scum if they visited me and didn't confess when pressed. Still, if someone wants to use me to confirm an action that is possible.



theprof00 said:
@ wonk
Linkz is claiming that the flavor cleared him.
You say baal has no reason for questioning it? Well where is the reasoning behind the flavor clearing him.
sorry but the only 100% clearings imo are made by a cop, with his own flip confirming that hes not paranoid. Everyone else is just varying levels of certainty, and you specifically should not be treating linkz as cleared like that.

You two. Id like everyone to take a look at your affiliation with each other. You vote together. Defend each other. Believe each other 100%.
HoS both of you.


The flavor confimed that he knew that he had been targeted before the flavor came up or he was able to somehow tell stefl to make a flavor. The fact the person who targeted him hasn't come forward makes me a little more suspect however it is more than enough reason to not go after him for now. Although at this point I do think linkz should say the person to help lower the pool further.

When have I ever said he was cleared 100% I haven't even said to you guys should think me cleared 100% since there is the possibility of people lying.



Nothing about that was in any way a revenge vote spurge. If you honestly think I'm the serial killer, then it is in your best interest to go after somebody else, because it would be in my best interest to gun down the mafia.



Money can't buy happiness. Just video games, which make me happy.