By using this site, you agree to our Privacy Policy and our Terms of Use. Close

Forums - General Discussion - Mafia Round 36 - Suikoden II

Final-Fan said:
Wonk was my "NIV"

@ spurge: No, because the only reason you're not on the list is I think it's fairly likely you were investigated already.

P.S. @ MOD: Suppose a vote in fact went to someone who had already been investigated. Would it really "double up" and be wasted, or would it default to the next most popular investigation?


Good question, even if it does double up, this post feels like a solid town investigation to me.



Around the Network

I voted Wonk



I voted prof in the investigation.

Also, as a sidenote, I gotta say I do not like the flavors, Baalz's were much better.



theprof00 said:
Linkzmax said:
theprof00 said:
Linkzmax said:
theprof00 said:
Doesn't answer my statement.
zany before practical.

Are you that bad at comprehension? You are not a watcher.

Your post actually reads that that's what you think I am. So sorry for your confusion.

So I don't mention the only other possible role that you could be certain of not being targeted for doc or kill and I leave out an explanation of why you're not the watcher, and that's because I think it's what you actually are?

Not a bad idea Vette. I voted for Baal.

Maybe if you hadn't arbitrarily said I wasn't the other two.

I voted Baal.


You say you weren't the target of the doc or kill.

Links ask you how you knew.

You say you are joking.

Links says it wasn't funny because that was hinting at Paranoid Gun Owner. And you should have said something sooner.

You say how it's odd he jumps to that over watcher, doc, or commuter.

He explains how commuter and doc don't make sence.

Then you think he is sure you are a watcher when he had already skipped it to begin with? When he said PGO right at the start.

I don't think Linkz was the one confused here.



Linkzmax said:
theprof00 said:
Doesn't answer my statement.
zany before practical.

Are you that bad at comprehension? You are not a watcher.


So do you at leaste have some info to go along with this claim?



Around the Network
Wonktonodi said:
theprof00 said:
Linkzmax said:
theprof00 said:
Linkzmax said:
theprof00 said:
Doesn't answer my statement.
zany before practical.

Are you that bad at comprehension? You are not a watcher.

Your post actually reads that that's what you think I am. So sorry for your confusion.

So I don't mention the only other possible role that you could be certain of not being targeted for doc or kill and I leave out an explanation of why you're not the watcher, and that's because I think it's what you actually are?

Not a bad idea Vette. I voted for Baal.

Maybe if you hadn't arbitrarily said I wasn't the other two.

I voted Baal.


You say you weren't the target of the doc or kill.

Links ask you how you knew.

You say you are joking.

Links says it wasn't funny because that was hinting at Paranoid Gun Owner. And you should have said something sooner.

You say how it's odd he jumps to that over watcher, doc, or commuter.

He explains how commuter and doc don't make sence.

Then you think he is sure you are a watcher when he had already skipped it to begin with? When he said PGO right at the start.

I don't think Linkz was the one confused here.

Whatever. I could be a ballsy doc, or a vaguely speaking commuter. I'm known for both of those traits as it is.

Jumping to PGO didn't make any sense, period. But if he's claiming watcher, then I have nothing more to pursue. Had he not claimed watcher, I'd have theorized that he was trying to get me lynching by painting me as a threat to town and a good option for lynch as I could even be scum (a lynch with a mislynch silver lining of not hurting the town).

 

 



Furthermore saying that it was a hint is just as bad.
It was an obvious joke.



I voted for Wonk last night.



Money can't buy happiness. Just video games, which make me happy.

Wonktonodi said:
Linkzmax said:
theprof00 said:
Doesn't answer my statement.
zany before practical.

Are you that bad at comprehension? You are not a watcher.


So do you at leaste have some info to go along with this claim?

Nope, I'm a self-watcher only and nobody has visited me yet. It's not only a night ability though, as I was hinting here in case I died at night, nobody visited me during the day yesterday either. I'm not sure how Stefl will announce my role if/when I flip, but I didn't want anyone thinking I had clearing/damning evidence for/against anyone.



theprof00 said:

Whatever. I could be a ballsy doc, or a vaguely speaking commuter. I'm known for both of those traits as it is.

Jumping to PGO didn't make any sense, period. But if he's claiming watcher, then I have nothing more to pursue. Had he not claimed watcher, I'd have theorized that he was trying to get me lynching by painting me as a threat to town and a good option for lynch as I could even be scum (a lynch with a mislynch silver lining of not hurting the town).

"I'm certain I didn't draw a doc or kill." still doesn't fit a ballsy doc because while you would know if you did or didn't protect yourself, you couldn't be certain if you were the target for the kill or not. Nor would it fit for a vaguely speaking commuter.

PGO makes perfect sense knowing you couldn't be watcher and nothing else really fits the statement. I was hoping you would call it crazy and, as scum, fakehint at something more sane,(yet incredibly ballsy as scum to fakeclaim) namely watcher. I was never intending to label you as PGO and have you lynched for it. That's a completely nonsensical thing to push because it would require you to actually claim PGO. You'd have no reason to deny it as town.

I know I'm guilty of thinking the intention of what I say is obvious, but I don't think the tone of it is as clear as you believe it was. You know what sounds more like a joke? "I'm certain I wasn't killed last night"