By using this site, you agree to our Privacy Policy and our Terms of Use. Close

Forums - General Discussion - Mafia Round 36 - Suikoden II

theprof00 on 09 December 2011
Baalzamon said:
Fair enough.

In no particular order, Wonk, Spurgeon, and Radish.

Wonk has been acting different than normal in my opinion this game. Whether this means he is mafia or not is unknown.

Spurgeon didn't fall for the Prof trick, but I'm still just really not sure about him.

As for Radish, he is acting a lot like the normal radish, but the whole "So we have a roleblocker" right after Linkz and I just discussed how it could be a doctor or a roleblocker irks me.

Linkz nearly insisting on doc coupled with Radish popping up to say it's a roleblocker could be a "hey guys, we definitely didn't talk last night, we are in no way connected, we aren't even on the same page" kinda thing.

Spurgeon, I really don't know. He reminds me of Hat not being able to answer a question with any kind of actual answer. But his noobishness makes me feel like he's trying to hint at his character to prove his town allegiance, which I can see making sense to a noob.



Around the Network
Linkzmax on 09 December 2011
theprof00 said:
Linkzmax said:
theprof00 said:
Linkzmax said:
theprof00 said:

He's right, Baal. Because I listed my top three and I'm certain I didn't draw a doc or kill.

How are you certain you didn't draw them?

It's a joke.

Well I didn't find it funny, and not because I was one of the three you listed.(or at least at some point I was) I thought you were hinting PGO and I'd have been mad if you didn't make it clear you shouldn't be targeted by doc, cop, or any other pro-town roles.

So you'll consider the zaniest of scenarios but not the obvious ones?

Considering either doc or holding back a kill, no mention of roleblocker.

Considering me being a PGO, and not a watcher who watched myself, or a commuter, or even the doc myself.

You wouldn't know if you were protected/targeted if you're a commuter and I didn't think you'd bring that kind of attention if you were the doc, nor do you believe a doc should be able to protect themselves.



VGC Mafia Archives

theprof00 on 09 December 2011
Linkzmax said:
theprof00 said:

So you'll consider the zaniest of scenarios but not the obvious ones?

Considering either doc or holding back a kill, no mention of roleblocker.

Considering me being a PGO, and not a watcher who watched myself, or a commuter, or even the doc myself.

You wouldn't know if you were protected/targeted if you're a commuter and I didn't think you'd bring that kind of attention if you were the doc, nor do you believe a doc should be able to protect themselves.

irrelevant. If I can't protect myself or didn't, I wasn't killed. The statement is correct. I'm not the doc fyi, just pointing out that foible.

Hmmm. maybe I'm a watcher?



Linkzmax on 09 December 2011
spurgeonryan said:
radishhead said:
I'm up for investigating spurge (still got a feeling that he's not to be trusted), Linkz (that comment about having himself investigated felt like a bluff) and Wonk for pushing this top-3 votes thing on us quite hard


I've gotten that my enire life, but all I need is for someone to give me a chance.

 

 

@thread

Let's investigate the Prof. I do not think he has anything to hide so there should be no problem. Plus if he does really have nothing to hide he will be safe from us, and the Mafia may think something is up with him and leave him alone as well. When it is all said and done we may be doing him a favor!

Unless half of us are lying, then it will not help.


If prof isn't mafia, then mafia will believe he's town, and even if he's third-party he'd be a threat. They're not simply going to leave him alone.

 

@prof:
Lines


Lines



VGC Mafia Archives

Wonktonodi on 09 December 2011
spurgeonryan said:
I would post my top three, but I am on thin ice!


AS for the scum basing their kill on who people list, what else would they base their kill on? Its like an advertisement. You go to the store to get medicine, what do you look for at first? Names you are familiar with. They seem to have time on their side, so they waited. What are they waiting for?


just do it



Around the Network
Wonktonodi on 09 December 2011
Final-Fan said:
Baalzamon said:
I'm saying to reveal the top three people we believe should be investigated is stupid. All it does is place a target on each person who lists a mafia member. For the mafia to kill somebody who doesn't want to investigate them is downright stupid.

Oh, I thought you meant you wanted to kill anyone who did like: 

1.  The mafia
2.  Baalzamon
3.  Digimon


and your top 3?



Linkzmax on 09 December 2011
spurgeonryan said:
Linkzmax said:

If prof isn't mafia, then mafia will believe he's town, and even if he's third-party he'd be a threat. They're not simply going to leave him alone.

Stranger things have been going on this round, what makes you so sure? -,-

What's been strange?

Anyone confirmed as Town to everyone else is going to be a high priority for mafia.



VGC Mafia Archives

Wonktonodi on 09 December 2011

I am trying to get the town to take it's head out of the sand



TruckOSaurus on 09 December 2011

Tagged



Signature goes here!

Linkzmax on 09 December 2011

Not that we know if everyone went with the last-minute proposal of last night, but I don't believe Wonk or Baal should be in the top three. Don't want to chance having the same person investigated twice.



VGC Mafia Archives