By using this site, you agree to our Privacy Policy and our Terms of Use. Close

Forums - General Discussion - Mafia Round 36 - Suikoden II

NoCtiS_NoX said:
What's happening to the site? It's getting slow and can't access the site until now? Ugh!

Now you have access. Can you post your thoughts so far, because you really havent contributed to the game thus far.



Around the Network
Linkzmax said:
I don't know what tricks they may have to think of why they might, and even then there's very little reason not to want to reduce town's numbers. Which is why I said I don't believe they wouldn't kill.

We can rule out the silly idea of a mafia bus driver though. No chance of a non-kill if that OP role exists.

Ok then, if I can just piggyback onto your post then.

It is reasonable to think that the doc protected a townie. It is not 100% certain, since we don't know what kind of roles we are dealing with on the mafia side, or what their strategy is.

Generally, holding a kill would either mean they are extremely confident, or extremely desperate. Confident that none of them are suspected and they have plenty of time to attempt stunts like these.....desperate that they would attempt something so rash and forgo a kill.



theprof00 said:
Wonktonodi said:
Baalzamon said:
I'm saying to reveal the top three people we believe should be investigated is stupid. All it does is place a target on each person who lists a mafia member. For the mafia to kill somebody who doesn't want to investigate them is downright stupid.

The point of saying the top 3 is so that we as a town can reduce the possibility of scum messing with the night investigation.

You make it out like the scum will base their nightkill decision soley on who people list. That is just nonsence. It's not like a persons top 3 can't chance durring the day or the coarse of a game.So mafia taking someone out for thinking they shoudl be investigate won't always be their best move. Not to mention if everyone did list their top 3 and mafia would be stupid not to kill the person who listed them. Wouldn't that mean the next day the town would just go after the people listed by the dead man. So it would then be stupid for the scum to kill the people listed and so on. In otherwords WIFORM for the scum to worry about. Not a reason for the town to give up its power.

So if you are done trying to scare people please tell me your top 3.

He's right, Baal. Because I listed my top three and I'm certain I didn't draw a doc or kill.

How are you certain you didn't draw them?



spurgeonryan said:
I would post my top three, but I am on thin ice!


AS for the scum basing their kill on who people list, what else would they base their kill on? Its like an advertisement. You go to the store to get medicine, what do you look for at first? Names you are familiar with. They seem to have time on their side, so they waited. What are they waiting for?

What makes you say you're on thin ice?



Linkzmax said:
theprof00 said:
Wonktonodi said:
Baalzamon said:
I'm saying to reveal the top three people we believe should be investigated is stupid. All it does is place a target on each person who lists a mafia member. For the mafia to kill somebody who doesn't want to investigate them is downright stupid.

The point of saying the top 3 is so that we as a town can reduce the possibility of scum messing with the night investigation.

You make it out like the scum will base their nightkill decision soley on who people list. That is just nonsence. It's not like a persons top 3 can't chance durring the day or the coarse of a game.So mafia taking someone out for thinking they shoudl be investigate won't always be their best move. Not to mention if everyone did list their top 3 and mafia would be stupid not to kill the person who listed them. Wouldn't that mean the next day the town would just go after the people listed by the dead man. So it would then be stupid for the scum to kill the people listed and so on. In otherwords WIFORM for the scum to worry about. Not a reason for the town to give up its power.

So if you are done trying to scare people please tell me your top 3.

He's right, Baal. Because I listed my top three and I'm certain I didn't draw a doc or kill.

How are you certain you didn't draw them?

It's a joke.



Around the Network

My top 3 for NIV would be prof, Vette, and myself. prof so I don't end up tunneling pointlessly. Vette because I feel pretty good about him, but in case he dips into inactivity again. Myself, well why not?



theprof00 said:
Linkzmax said:
theprof00 said:

He's right, Baal. Because I listed my top three and I'm certain I didn't draw a doc or kill.

How are you certain you didn't draw them?

It's a joke.

Well I didn't find it funny, and not because I was one of the three you listed.(or at least at some point I was) I thought you were hinting PGO and I'd have been mad if you didn't make it clear you shouldn't be targeted by doc, cop, or any other pro-town roles.



I'm up for investigating spurge (still got a feeling that he's not to be trusted), Linkz (that comment about having himself investigated felt like a bluff) and Wonk for pushing this top-3 votes thing on us quite hard



Click this button, you know you want to!  [Subscribe]

Watch me on YouTube!

http://www.youtube.com/user/TheRadishBros

~~~~ Mario Kart 8 drove far past my expectations! Never again will I doubt the wheels of a Monster Franchise! :0 ~~~~

Fair enough.

In no particular order, Wonk, Spurgeon, and Radish.

Wonk has been acting different than normal in my opinion this game. Whether this means he is mafia or not is unknown.

Spurgeon didn't fall for the Prof trick, but I'm still just really not sure about him.

As for Radish, he is acting a lot like the normal radish, but the whole "So we have a roleblocker" right after Linkz and I just discussed how it could be a doctor or a roleblocker irks me.



Money can't buy happiness. Just video games, which make me happy.

Linkzmax said:
theprof00 said:
Linkzmax said:
theprof00 said:

He's right, Baal. Because I listed my top three and I'm certain I didn't draw a doc or kill.

How are you certain you didn't draw them?

It's a joke.

Well I didn't find it funny, and not because I was one of the three you listed.(or at least at some point I was) I thought you were hinting PGO and I'd have been mad if you didn't make it clear you shouldn't be targeted by doc, cop, or any other pro-town roles.

So you'll consider the zaniest of scenarios but not the obvious ones?

Considering either doc or holding back a kill, no mention of roleblocker.

Considering me being a PGO, and not a watcher who watched myself, or a commuter, or even the doc myself.