I didn't really like the prof lynch at the time either, but I did want it over no lynch. I am glad the extension went through though. I probably would have unvoted prof, but I don't like a radish lynch one bit so I'm keeping it placed.

I don't think your reasoning fits radish at all.

What's going on?  Well, to start the day, Prof lied out of his ass, and attempted to get spurgeon to admit being mafia.  We can either conclude that spurgeon had people helping him, and thus was able to thwart this attempt, or spurgeon isn't mafia, and was confused because of this.

Nothing about this was in any way scummy by Prof.  As a matter of fact, why in the hell would a scum lie about being a cop, and try getting a noob to admit being mafia?  It doesn't even make sense.

Other than that, there has simply been discussion about whether or not we should reveal who we will vote for with our investigation vote.

I'm sort of confused how somebody can't have an "understanding" of what is going on.

In regards to the investigation vote, simply putting an ounce of thought into it, it seems rather obvious that mafia do not themselves have a vote in it.  In a game with 11 players, we likely have 3 mafia.  So people here honestly think the mafia is going to get 3 out of 11 votes for who the investigation goes on?  I don't think Stefl would allow this.

Also, for those who think we should reveal who we will vote for with the investigation, it still makes no sense how this will help us in any way.

Wonk has been a bit unclear in his reasoning, but he did open my eyes a bit. When you told FF he didn't have a vote because he was scum, that could have been a slip on your part. Also as Wonk has said, I want a lynch and yours was the only one I foresaw being able to happen within the timelimit. It's not as if I slipped the vote in at the last minute or didn't try to extend the day so there'd be more discussion and a likely better candidate for the gallows.

I do wonder how you missed the votals which declared you'd be lynched as of the standings at that time.

If its as simple as putting an ounce of thought into it to come to that conclusion, then why do the rules state this.  The last line is the most important, I'll underline it,  dont need you using more than an ounce of thought

Night Investigation Vote:

- You are allowed to not cast a vote. If you don't want to vote, write my a PM stating that.
- A Draw will give the investigator the posibility to choose his target freely, between the persons who got the most votes
- You are not allowed to cast your vote publically, you have to PM me for it to take effect
- You are not allowed to misuse the mechanic behind it, you may ask for people to vote for a person, but not force them
- You are not allowed to force anyone to claim who they nighttime voted for
- Missusing the nighttime investigation vote may result in losing the ability to vote, the investigator losing his investigative Ability or Mafia manipulating the vote completely

"Wow [prof], you don't even have a shread of reasoning."

Spurge- that's the most blatant revenge vote I've ever seen, and it looks crazy suspicious to me, especially as I know that I'm town-aligned - I know, because I've tried to disguise a revenge vote before- it's not very well hidden, I'm afraid. Whether you're town or not, I seriously recommend reconsidering that vote, because if I get lynched then you're going to be seriously considered for a lynch tomorrow due to your reckless actions

So it's between me and 4 less experienced players eh?

Anyways, I'm not opposed to being investigated. It won't nail scum, but as you've said that means that though they'd love to eliminate me, doc-fear will push them to choose freely between everyone else in town. So in turn you're saying you want me around, yay! It'd be nice to go into day two as "confirmed" town too, since the cop need not come forward if everyone knows I was the target and nobody will point a guilty finger at me.(Be forewarned, I await your fear mongering)

Do people simply ignore posts from mods, Stefl in particular? He had just posted votals declaring the day would be over in 10 hours before your NL vote. C'mon bud you're often chastised for missing things, do try to pay attention.

Really looking forward to the answer to this. prof went from stating mafia have no vote, to being first to declare all mafia had a vote, and finally this.

You get me Wonk, you really get me!

I really hope you're town, because I'm finding you easier to read after I've called you scum and you actually react.(no more rolling over!) Here it was more your general behavior though.