By using this site, you agree to our Privacy Policy and our Terms of Use. Close

Forums - Sales - PAL Charts - Week 44

The_Joker_Product on 09 November 2011
shanbcn said:
kowenicki said:
shanbcn said:
GT5 outsold Forza 4 in Spain last month.

that doesnt surprise me one bit.


But then that doesnt explain Forza 4 sales in EMEEA.

Dont forget that this site isnt really very accurate.

Halo Reach numbers there are at 4.7 million as of September but according to this site its at 6.7 million, overtracked nearly 2 million. MGS4 is very undertracked as well because it has not sold only 600,000 copies since week 10.

They never seem to fix the software sales though.



Around the Network
D-Joe on 09 November 2011
ethomaz said:
D-Joe said:
ethomaz said:
Nsanity said:
Stadelhuber said:
And ethomaz with his usually biased analysis. Boring.

I remeber a while back VGChartz Killzone 3 numbers were higher than of NPD, then you have had ethomaz going on about them not being accurate or how they dont include bundles and what not...so yeah double standards much.

Just talking about Americas...

Killzone 3 sales in first week without bundles: 253,695 (http://gamrconnect.vgchartz.com/thread.php?id=125462)

Killzone 3 sales in first week after ajusted bundles: 311,296

Ouch!!!

And NPD don't track hardware bundles... just software bundles.

ouch for you right,60%

you think people forget what you said and what you try at NPD June thread right

Because NPD was forced to put shipped X360 in numbers

worst joke ever
so you believe Pachter now?



http://zh-tw.justin.tv/johndoe1899

ethomaz on 09 November 2011
D-Joe said:
ethomaz said:
D-Joe said:
ethomaz said:
Nsanity said:
Stadelhuber said:
And ethomaz with his usually biased analysis. Boring.

I remeber a while back VGChartz Killzone 3 numbers were higher than of NPD, then you have had ethomaz going on about them not being accurate or how they dont include bundles and what not...so yeah double standards much.

Just talking about Americas...

Killzone 3 sales in first week without bundles: 253,695 (http://gamrconnect.vgchartz.com/thread.php?id=125462)

Killzone 3 sales in first week after ajusted bundles: 311,296

Ouch!!!

And NPD don't track hardware bundles... just software bundles.

ouch for you right,60%

you think people forget what you said and what you try at NPD June thread right

Because NPD was forced to put shipped X360 in numbers

worst joke ever

Joke? LOL seem more like FACT .

Edit - MS shipped numbers confirmed that... I don't need to believe in Patcher.



D-Joe on 09 November 2011
ethomaz said:
D-Joe said:
ethomaz said:
D-Joe said:
ethomaz said:
Nsanity said:
Stadelhuber said:
And ethomaz with his usually biased analysis. Boring.

I remeber a while back VGChartz Killzone 3 numbers were higher than of NPD, then you have had ethomaz going on about them not being accurate or how they dont include bundles and what not...so yeah double standards much.

Just talking about Americas...

Killzone 3 sales in first week without bundles: 253,695 (http://gamrconnect.vgchartz.com/thread.php?id=125462)

Killzone 3 sales in first week after ajusted bundles: 311,296

Ouch!!!

And NPD don't track hardware bundles... just software bundles.

ouch for you right,60%

you think people forget what you said and what you try at NPD June thread right

Because NPD was forced to put shipped X360 in numbers

worst joke ever

Joke? LOL seem more like FACT .

Edit - MS shipped numbers confirmed that... I don't need to believe in Patcher.

wow you're crazy

FACT?MS shipped numbers confiremd that?more like you believe that



http://zh-tw.justin.tv/johndoe1899

ethomaz on 09 November 2011
kowenicki said:
ethomaz said:
shanbcn said:
Flippozzo said:

 

Great numbers and like many have said before  that Reach is overtracked by quite a bit on VGZ. I think its overtracked by atleast 1m and must likely close to 1.5m.

VGC for 1st Oct.

6,641,995

Americas of course... yeah way overtracked.

Anyway... that's a PAL thread... anybody can open a thread for America.

Need to factor in bundles and rest of americas, but yes it may be overtracked.... my question is... so?

It is also a shame the chart doesnt go down to the top 30 so we can check how overtracked the sony exclusives are....

 

Software tracking isnt an exact science, never has been.  NPD might be wrong.... VGC might be wrong....?

I don't care if it is over or under... I just put the VGC numbers into evidence for people who want to read.

If you don't like... just ignore.

Anyway... that's a PAL thread like I said before.



Around the Network
ethomaz on 09 November 2011

D-Joe said:

wow you're crazy

FACT?MS shipped numbers confiremd that?more like you believe that

Belive in what you believe... if NPD was right about 360 the MS's shippements would be higher for the last quarter... so NPD counted shipped X360 to Latin America under Microsoft's pressure (in italic is my own opinion... not proved fact).

This is a PAL thread... I'm done here.



D-Joe on 09 November 2011
ethomaz said:

D-Joe said:

wow you're crazy

FACT?MS shipped numbers confiremd that?more like you believe that

Belive in what you believe... if NPD was right about 360 the MS's shippements would be higher for the last quarter... so NPD conted shipped X360.

This is a PAL thread... I'm done here.

低能

not just MS,even Nintendo and Sony sometimes shippment lower or much higher than sales,how can this be "confiremd"?are you kidding me?

you always done here



http://zh-tw.justin.tv/johndoe1899

ethomaz on 09 November 2011
kowenicki said:
ethomaz said:

D-Joe said:

wow you're crazy

FACT?MS shipped numbers confiremd that?more like you believe that

Belive in what you believe... if NPD was right about 360 the MS's shippements would be higher for the last quarter... so NPD counted shipped X360 to Latin America under Microsoft's pressure (in italic is my own opinion... not proved fact).

This is a PAL thread... I'm done here.


lol. wtf are you talking about... thats nonsense.

and so you aren't actually interested in a pal thread... but you just dipped in to use one of your two favourite words?

I'm always interested in pal threads... I junt don't like to talk about Americas numbers in a pal thread.

Like I said before... anybody open a thread about this chartz and I can talk about with more information and facts .

Camon Kowen... you know my reputation and accuracy with the numbers ... I can be biased with comments but numbers not.



shanbcn on 09 November 2011
D-Joe said:
shanbcn said:
kowenicki said:
shanbcn said:
GT5 outsold Forza 4 in Spain last month.

that doesnt surprise me one bit.


But then that doesnt explain Forza 4 sales in EMEEA.

first i wanna know where they said GT5 outsold Forza in Spain Oct(even it doesn't for me too)

second how is that hard to explain,like Forza 4 sold 107k in UK FW,you really think can't sold 170k in outside of UK?looks at the ratio


Its not hard to guess which sold more after looking at chart. Both are at 7th position on their platform, GT5 must likely sold 2 times more then Forza 4.



D-Joe on 09 November 2011
shanbcn said:
D-Joe said:
shanbcn said:
kowenicki said:
shanbcn said:
GT5 outsold Forza 4 in Spain last month.

that doesnt surprise me one bit.


But then that doesnt explain Forza 4 sales in EMEEA.

first i wanna know where they said GT5 outsold Forza in Spain Oct(even it doesn't for me too)

second how is that hard to explain,like Forza 4 sold 107k in UK FW,you really think can't sold 170k in outside of UK?looks at the ratio


Its not hard to guess which sold more after looking at chart. Both are at 7th position on their platform, GT5 must likely sold 2 times more then Forza 4.

um,Forza 4 is 5th and 7th



http://zh-tw.justin.tv/johndoe1899