By using this site, you agree to our Privacy Policy and our Terms of Use. Close

Forums - Sony - Uncharted 3 Review Thread!

Tagged games:

Moren on 24 October 2011
Andrespetmonkey said:
Fuck sake, G4TV gave it an 8.

Weren't they calling Uncharted 3 the reincarnation of God or something



Around the Network
Aldro on 24 October 2011
crissindahouse said:

yeah why? it's not fair to hope that other games will go down. the guys behind that games don't deserve it like you say the guys from naughty dog don't deserve "bad" reviews. if you think like that you aren't a cool fan like a thought then you're only a sad fanboy.

 

..Im a fanboy, this is news to you?

^^



Aldro on 24 October 2011
ethomaz said:
pezus said:
Batman is at 96, UC3 at 94. Batman will most likely end at 95 and UC3 at 93 or 94.

Batman already at 95... the PS3 page lacks reviews (26 vs. over 50).

This.

 

Meta is just lazy. Itll get up there soon enough. The 360 reviews are mostly PS3 aswell. Its just a sloppy updating of Meta. Batman will finish 94-96. Uncharted 3 92-94. It could be a tie...



ethomaz on 24 October 2011

More perfect score add to Metacritc... now 11.

94 based on 31 Critics.



Wagram on 24 October 2011

G4TV review also makes no sense. Lives in the shadow of U2.

Apparently Call of Duty isn't the same game every time. I must have fallen and bumped my head to think that.



Around the Network
crissindahouse on 24 October 2011
Aldro said:
crissindahouse said:

yeah why? it's not fair to hope that other games will go down. the guys behind that games don't deserve it like you say the guys from naughty dog don't deserve "bad" reviews. if you think like that you aren't a cool fan like a thought then you're only a sad fanboy.

 

..Im a fanboy, this is news to you?

^^

no that's what i'm saying i thought yu are a cool fan or a cool fanboy who respects others.

i'm a little xbox 360 fanboy as well but i would never hope that uncharted will get worse reviews just to see halo in front of it. i am a huge elder scrolls fan and i hope skyrim will win the goty award but i won't hope to see bad reviews for uncharted to make it easier because that would be unfair to the naughty dog guys. (yes im a very nice character guy haha)



Aldro on 24 October 2011
crissindahouse said:
Aldro said:
crissindahouse said:

yeah why? it's not fair to hope that other games will go down. the guys behind that games don't deserve it like you say the guys from naughty dog don't deserve "bad" reviews. if you think like that you aren't a cool fan like a thought then you're only a sad fanboy.

 

..Im a fanboy, this is news to you?

^^

no that's what i'm saying i thought yu are a cool fan or a cool fanboy who respects others.

i'm a little xbox 360 fanboy as well but i would never hope that uncharted will get worse reviews just to see halo in front of it. i am a huge elder scrolls fan and i hope skyrim will win the goty award but i won't hope to see bad reviews for uncharted to make it easier because that would be unfair to the naughty dog guys. (yes im a very nice character guy haha)

Then we are different fanboys ^_^.



Boutros on 24 October 2011

I believe a perfect score from IGN might be a bit exaggerated but that 8 from Eurogamer is an insult to the whole industry.



Aldro on 24 October 2011
pezus said:
Aldro said:
ethomaz said:
pezus said:
Batman is at 96, UC3 at 94. Batman will most likely end at 95 and UC3 at 93 or 94.

Batman already at 95... the PS3 page lacks reviews (26 vs. over 50).

This.

 

Meta is just lazy. Itll get up there soon enough. The 360 reviews are mostly PS3 aswell. Its just a sloppy updating of Meta. Batman will finish 94-96. Uncharted 3 92-94. It could be a tie...

Nope I think most of those 360 reviews won't be added for the PS3. Look at other multiplatform games, 360 almost always has more reviews 

Really?

The 360 version has 54
PS3 has 26

That's less than half the amount of the 360 reviews! Okay if its like 80-90 reviews to the 360 and 60-70 to the PS3. But trust me, there will be more.



ethomaz on 24 October 2011

Another 10/10 on meta... 12 and counting.