Why would I give Final-Fan the one role that would save his ass?

Wrong answer. Why would you hesitate to provide a role another player could confirm as theirs? I call your bluff sir... unless you enable me to believe you by stating the 3rd role, and have another player confirm it.

I will however wait for F-F to roleclaim before you provide us with the third role however. I think that's fair enough.

F-F, get your ass in here and roleclaim. If your claim matches Trucks 3rd role. I'll believe you are town. If Trucks is town, he will have no problem clarifying you as town. If you and him differ, either you are truly scum (another player can confirm the 3rd role exists) or Trucks is bluffing, and we lynch his ass for this gutsy gambit.

I think that plan is pretty air tight. Refusal to follow this plan pretty much proves you are scum.

What do you think trucks?

Bolded was directed mainly at F-F

Back, and before I can give my opinion, I need to make sure I'm understanding this right. Was that not actually a generic night kill but some other action?

Don't worry before this day is over, I'll give you the town role and both scum roles.

OP says "murdered" so I'll take it as just that.

In that case, I'll say the following. Assuming the loss of vote and the kill involved separate mafia roles/characters, Radish isn't mafia. You might want to get your vote off of him immediately hat.

So now our pool is limited to Wonk Trucks and F-F. Town wins :D

Don't get me wrong, as soon as F-F refuses to follow my suggested plan, or unless he comes up with the precise role Trucks obtained from his detective work -that is then confirmed by nobody challenging it; I'll switch my vote to to him [F-F]

Radish being town does not wave the possibility of Trucks trying to pull off a quick bluff.

Yes. Essentially, if you're being true to us, process of elimination points to Wonk being F-F's scum buddy. And town wins, unless there's a 3rd scum which I doubt.

The bolded is why I insist F-F and Trucks follow through the plan. The way I see it, this is more likely a bluff on Trucks side. Notice how trucks jokingly says I should have taken a guess. In his dreams... the fact that he said that tells me he was disappointed that I didn't allow him the opportunity to feel out what I know, and what I meant when I said I would challenge him if he gave the wrong reason. Therefore, he took the safe route and said he was a detective instead of a cop. It's a safe claim because a real cop would confront his claim. In this case, me saying I would challenge him if he didn't provide a sound reason forced him to make that safe claim. Can I be wrong? Absolutely, but I insist that we make sure we F-F is scum before we lynch him.

F-F, if you have nothing to fear, you will roleclaim. Only your roleclaim can clear you if you are really town.

A detective getting 3 roles from an investigation ... and 3 roles from the actual game no less ... all it would take is 2 days and Trucks could have at least 50% of the roles in the game. This stinks ... this fucking stinks trucks. Your roleclaim, really really stinks. Did I mention how much your role stinks, trucks?

Grrr, F-F get in  herE! My brain has to know that this is a bluff!

Day ends in 63 hours, 53 minutes.

With 5 players eligible to vote, a majority requires 3 votes.

Votals:
[1] radishhead: hatmoza
[1] hatmoza: radishhead
[1] Final-Fan: TruckOSaurus

By player:
hatmoza: radishhead
radishhead: hatmoza
TruckOSaurus: Final-Fan