Infamous 2 and Motorstorm Apocalypse deserved SO much higher IMO. SOCOM was a dissapointment gameplay wise so that is not a surprise.. most games did a little worse then I foudn them to be but overall the rest is decently scored.

Killzone 3 and inFamous 2 should have scored higher, like 88-90 range, LBP2 and the Show look right. I have Resistance 3 but haven't played yet so I cant argue one way or the other. SOCOM 4 does not deserve that low of a score, I would say 75ish, the others I cannot comment on as I don't have them. But the Motorstorm games were always good games, so a 77 is a good score.

Killzone should have been over 90. i really enjoyed it. I think the score for Motorstorm is ok. cant say anything about the others but i will definetly buy socom and infamous later

I guess it depends on the review scale being used. I've only played two games from the list so far (LBP2 and Killzone 3). LBP2 sits right around where I think it belongs although I would rate in a bit higher. Killzone 3 is a little too high. I haven't really thought a lot about its score, but just off the top of my head, I would give it closer to a 75. That being said, if you are talking about where Killzone 3's score ranks in comparison to other games in its genre that have been released this year, I actually think it is underrated. I really am perplexed as to how Bulletstorm and Crysis 2 have comparable scores to Killzone 3.....just baffles me. While I haven't played GoW Origins Collection, I would say the score is about accurate if the games are comparable to the PSP versions.

Hopefully, I will be picking up Infamous 2 and Resistance 3 in the coming months. Also, Disgaea 4 just released this week as well, but I don't know if enough people are playing it right now or if enough reviews have been submitted to really include it in the list.

Edit: I voted Yes, as I expected- probably not the ideal vote but the closest to my opinion.

Infamous and Motorstorm deserve more. KZ3 is a tad less than I thought. Everything else is less than their predecessors but it's what I expected taking higher standards into account. I'm surprised MLB gets 90+ again for the third year running. Surely its the same shit each year but what do I know.

Uncharted 3: Drake's Deception will top the list of exclusives, guaranteed.

Killzone 3 was the one game I was expecting great things from. In the end it's Metascore is about right, though. Excellent, but not masterly. Killzone 2 is a 90+ game. Killzone 3 is a low 80s for me.

Infamous 2 ended up where I thought it would, but after playing it, I must say it deserves more. It's a high 80s game for me.

Resistance 3... lower than I would have thought, considering Insomniac seemed determined to "fix" the series after the complaints of part 2, even though I LOVED it. Haven't played 3 yet though. Getting my copy tomorrow.

I think Uncharted 3 will get in the 90s, though not as high as Uncharted 2.

Metacritic is overrated. Disgaea is standing at 87. Higher than many of the PS3 exclusives released this year.

Thats because its the best ps3 exclusive of the year

lol, I doubt that many reviewers will even review this game. For instance MLB the show wasn't reviewed by that many people. Or at least the reviews weren't taken into consideration.