By using this site, you agree to our Privacy Policy and our Terms of Use. Close

Forums - Sony - What will be Sony's next 90+ rated Meta game (excluding Uncharted 3)?

 

Which game will be the first to reach 90 in metacritic?

Resistance 3 31 13.25%
 
Ratchet & Clank: All 4 One 3 1.28%
 
God of War: Origins 13 5.56%
 
ICO Collection 81 34.62%
 
Twisted Metal 4 1.71%
 
Starhawk 7 2.99%
 
The Last Guardian 70 29.91%
 
Other 25 10.68%
 
Total:234
TadpoleJackson on 08 August 2011
Lafiel said:
TadpoleJackson said:
Out of all the games they have announced I can't see any of their games making it 90+ on meta

good for you


Thanks =) 

I'm not sure why everyone else had a problem with my reasons, especially since I was one of the only ones who backed it up with anything substantial.

And yes, I know you are being sarcastic 

Max King of the Wild said:


So then scratch LBP and include LBP2 since they were firsrt party then and that was their first release being so. and thats more like 4. and I have no clue out of how many but who cares?


No, because that wouldn't have been there first PS3 game. So that makes two. 



Around the Network
Jay520 on 08 August 2011
coolbeans said:
What's with everyone attacking TadpoleJackson?

Initial question: Besides U3, what other PS3 exclusive do you see getting a 90+ meta?

Tadpole: I don't see any PS3 exclusive that has been announced to get a 90+ meta.

What further interrogation do you need to do on him? Whether a poll has it or not, "none of the above" can also be an option. I only put one word in my initial post, yet no one has asked me why I choose that. Move on, to keep this back on topic so posters can go back to focusing solely on their opinions rather than degrading another poster's...less agreeable opinion.



No one's attacking him, well at least I'm not. He made a prediction that I thought was interesting and was curious on his reasoning. If he didn't want people to be interested in his opinion, then he shouldn't have posted. This is a forum afterall.

TadpoleJackson on 08 August 2011
Jay520 said:
TadpoleJackson said:

2. MM wasn't a Sony studio with LBP. I remembered Santa Monica after my last post. That's 2 out of what 10 studios? I'm too lazy. what did Wipeout make? 

Studios that did reach 90 Meta their first time on PS3
- Media Molecule 
- Santa Monica
- Guerrilla Games

Studios that didn't reach 90 Meta their first time on PS3
- Polphony Digital
- Naughty Dog
- Zipper
- SCE San Diego
- SCE London
- Evolution Studios

So that's 3 vs 6. That's not that much of a recurring trend. 

TadpoleJackson said:

Besides Guerilla I can't think of one Sony 1st party dev that passed the 90+ on their first attempt on the PS3.

The Last Guardian won't be Team ICO's first game on the PS3, so it could still reach 90 meta following your rule.


Did you read the post you quoted? MM wasn't Sony 1st party when they released their first PS3 game 

What is Team Ico's other game? 



Jay520 on 08 August 2011
coolbeans said:
Jay520 said:
coolbeans said:
What's with everyone attacking TadpoleJackson?

Initial question: Besides U3, what other PS3 exclusive do you see getting a 90+ meta?

Tadpole: I don't see any PS3 exclusive that has been announced to get a 90+ meta.

What further interrogation do you need to do on him? Whether a poll has it or not, "none of the above" can also be an option. I only put one word in my initial post, yet no one has asked me why I choose that. Move on, to keep this back on topic so posters can go back to focusing solely on their opinions rather than degrading another poster's...less agreeable opinion.


No one's attacking him, well at I'm not. He made a prediction that I thought was interesting and was curious on his reasoning. If he didn't want people to be interested in his opinion, then he shouldn't have posted. This is a forum afterall.


I never said everyone; 

Yes you did.

coolbeans said:
What's with everyone attacking TadpoleJackson?


Max King of the Wild on 08 August 2011
TadpoleJackson said:
Lafiel said:
TadpoleJackson said:
Out of all the games they have announced I can't see any of their games making it 90+ on meta

good for you


Thanks =) 

I'm not sure why everyone else had a problem with my reasons, especially since I was one of the only ones who backed it up with anything substantial.

And yes, I know you are being sarcastic 

Max King of the Wild said:


So then scratch LBP and include LBP2 since they were firsrt party then and that was their first release being so. and thats more like 4. and I have no clue out of how many but who cares?


No, because that wouldn't have been there first PS3 game. So that makes two. 


I love your made up trivial regulations to be able to support what you said... next you'll cancel KZ2 and GoW3 because they weren't new IP's or something...



Around the Network
Jay520 on 08 August 2011
TadpoleJackson said:

- Did you read the post you quoted? MM wasn't Sony 1st party when they released their first PS3 game 

- What is Team Ico's other game? 


- How would being first party or not affect a game's metascore? It's your rule, I guess. It doesn't make sense to me. It doesn't really seem like much of a trend that can be used to determine future happenings.

Either way, Killzone 2 and God of War 3 did it, so The Last Gaurdian can do it too. 

- Their other game is ICO Collection releasing next month.



Jay520 on 08 August 2011
coolbeans said:
^Edited to clarify. You still the rest is right.


Okay, I agree. Some people are attacking him.



TadpoleJackson on 08 August 2011
Jay520 said:
TadpoleJackson said:

- Did you read the post you quoted? MM wasn't Sony 1st party when they released their first PS3 game 

- What is Team Ico's other game? 


- How would being first party or not affect a game's metascore? It's your rule, I guess. It doesn't make sense to me. It doesn't really seem like much of a trend that can be used to determine future happenings.

Either way, Killzone 2 and God of War 3 did it, so The Last Gaurdian can do it too. 

2.- Their other game is ICO Collection releasing next month.
Max King of the Wild said:



I love your made up trivial regulations to be able to support what you said... next you'll cancel KZ2 and GoW3 because they weren't new IP's or something...

Fine, if you want, you can count them. Their first game for the PS3 was Rag Doll Kung Fu. I'm not going to look it up, but I'm pretty sure that it scored less than 90 on metacritic. My point still stands 

I was going to go into detail as to why I wasn't including second parties, and recently acquired studios, but now I don't have to. 

2. That's is being developed by Bluepoint games =) 



Jay520 on 08 August 2011
TadpoleJackson said:

I was going to go into detail as to why I wasn't including second parties, and recently acquired studios, but now I don't have to. 

2. That's is being developed by Bluepoint games =) 


Is this a reply to my GOW3/KZ2 statement, or are you replying to Man King of the Wild? Either way, please go into detail. I'm interested in your reasoning.

2. Nice one. : ). But you leave a hole in your argument. Blueprint Games is an independent company, which means ICO Collection could still recieve a 90 Meta. 



Max King of the Wild on 08 August 2011

http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Rag_Doll_Kung_Fu