No it's PS3 vs PS3 games just like VC vs GT5.

MG online didn't work for me when I tried, it kept saying searching for servers. And I waited for a long time...like 1/2 hour. Similar to GeoW 2.

I'm going to vote for Uncharted 2 on this one. Reason because while playing through GoW3 I realize not only how badass Kratos is but, I ended up hating him more. Kratos is just murdering people without a care in the world. That is my only reason.

btw, no contest! best boss fight ever!

Holy shit God of War 3 winning! Wow I was stupid I couldn't decide between the two but then I wrote my review comparing the basics and found out that Uncharted 2 had won just barely. But then I voted for God of War 3 and found out that it was already winning! Gosh that was pretty stupid

That's weird it worked fine for me

Both awesome near flawless games.

The only problem I had with Uncharted 2 was the silly end boss fight, the rest of the game was top notch. The collapsing building, train level and the Himalayan village were beyond all my expectations.

GoW3 was amazing throughout, but I had just played through the equally great GoW hd collection and apart from the graphics there wasn't a lot of innovation. Not that it needed it, it was great from start to finish. Fun puzzles, giant boss fights, great consistently beautiful artwork throughout.

Hard to choose. I'll go with Uncharted 2 since I replayed it's campaign one more time then GoW3. Now I feel like replaying both again.

I really enjoyed God of War 3 but I must say Uncharted 2 wins out pretty easily for me.

Both have among the best home console graphics out there. GoW's sense of scale is truly epic and the character detail is stunning. However the graphics in Uncharted 2 are just more polished to me and run smoother to boot (love the animation).

If you compare the writing, and especially, the voice acting, Uncharted wins hands down. All of the actors in U2 are top-notch, while GoW shines with some characters (Hephaestus and Hermes are among my favorites), but many others, like Kratos himself, are poor IMO (liked his voice acting just fine in the other games, just not part 3), and some are truly pathetic, such as Hades.

GoW3 starts out stronger though (the first level is a perfect 10!), while U2 didn't really start to blow me away until Borneo, but after that U2 never disappointed me (the last battle is a little weak, though), while GoW ranges from excellent (the Helios and Cronos levels especially) to a bit mundane.

Overall Uncharted 2 is just more interesting, has better control and is a more polished experience. God of War 3 is a great game while Uncharted 2 is truly a rare gem.

Well I beat MGS1 and 2, and I just don't like the type of story. MGS is basically a conspiracy theory game, with some dinosaurs with nukes. They are also not much game, and a lot of cinematic (beat MGS2 in 80 minutes on my second try by skipping the cinematics, but the game is a 10 hour game with them).

I'm just not a fan of conspiracy games. Just like "The Matrix" they are too silly for me. Halo is sci-fi shooter, it's not suppose to be realistic at all, just fun as hell, and it is.

I beat other MGS games (1 and 2), and MGS4 follows the same scheme. Even act 1 had more CG then game, I can only imagine how act 5 is. However I have seen my friend play some of the sillier moments of the game (Metal Gear Rex vs. Ray Boss fight, etc)

Anyway, onto this vote: Uncharted 2

No contest. Uncharted 2 had one of the best plots in a shooter I have ever seen, and Nathan Drake is funny. You rarely see a funny protagonist in a major shooter, usually your character is serious or mute. Great graphics, amazing pacing compared to the first, and well any other game. This is one of the rare games you can pick up, and have to force yourself to put down. Also at 10 hours long, it's longer then GoW, and with multiplayer, there is some replay.

Not a fan of God of War, at least not the console iterations. They strike me as a game purely about violence, there is little plot and well other then some very scripted boss fights, this game doesn't appeal to me at all.