By using this site, you agree to our Privacy Policy and our Terms of Use. Close

Forums - Microsoft - Rumor: Full Stereoscopic 3D Hitting Xbox 360

daroamer said:
ethomaz said:

daroamer said:

What does that even mean?

All polygon based games are created from the beginning to be 3D.  Why do you think computer animated cartoons look so great in 3D, because they are already created that way.

That's Naughty Dog saying... not me.

"I was talking to the studio guys [Naughty Dog] , I said 'How do you make it look it like that? Because it's different from any other 3D game I've ever seen.' And he said, 'We designed the game, planning on 3D. We went for maximum definition every frame.'" 

Come on, that's just marketing speak.  It falls in the camp of "we designed the game to use every last drop of power the PS3/360 can produce".

It's like when Avatar was first released on Blu-ray with no extras James Cameron went with "it's only because we wanted the picture and sound to be so good that we used all the available space on the disc".  Oh really?  Why didn't they just include a second disc?  It's because they wanted people to buy it twice.

No. That's Naughty Dog... when in a game they don't do what they say I will believe otherwise.

Meanwhile the 3D in Uncharted 3 could be something never seen in other games.



Around the Network
ethomaz said:
daroamer said:
ethomaz said:

daroamer said:

What does that even mean?

All polygon based games are created from the beginning to be 3D.  Why do you think computer animated cartoons look so great in 3D, because they are already created that way.

That's Naughty Dog saying... not me.

"I was talking to the studio guys [Naughty Dog] , I said 'How do you make it look it like that? Because it's different from any other 3D game I've ever seen.' And he said, 'We designed the game, planning on 3D. We went for maximum definition every frame.'" 

Come on, that's just marketing speak.  It falls in the camp of "we designed the game to use every last drop of power the PS3/360 can produce".

It's like when Avatar was first released on Blu-ray with no extras James Cameron went with "it's only because we wanted the picture and sound to be so good that we used all the available space on the disc".  Oh really?  Why didn't they just include a second disc?  It's because they wanted people to buy it twice.

No. That's Naughty Dog... when in a game they don't do what they say I will believe otherwise.

Meanwhile the 3D in Uncharted 3 could be something never seen in other games.

It's marketing speak but more power to you.



ethomaz said:
daroamer said:
ethomaz said:

daroamer said:

What does that even mean?

All polygon based games are created from the beginning to be 3D.  Why do you think computer animated cartoons look so great in 3D, because they are already created that way.

That's Naughty Dog saying... not me.

"I was talking to the studio guys [Naughty Dog] , I said 'How do you make it look it like that? Because it's different from any other 3D game I've ever seen.' And he said, 'We designed the game, planning on 3D. We went for maximum definition every frame.'" 

Come on, that's just marketing speak.  It falls in the camp of "we designed the game to use every last drop of power the PS3/360 can produce".

It's like when Avatar was first released on Blu-ray with no extras James Cameron went with "it's only because we wanted the picture and sound to be so good that we used all the available space on the disc".  Oh really?  Why didn't they just include a second disc?  It's because they wanted people to buy it twice.

No. That's Naughty Dog... when in a game they don't do what they say I will believe otherwise.

Meanwhile the 3D in Uncharted 3 could be something never seen in other games.


Are you serious right now?  I mean do you honestly buy into every single line of marketing that comes out of Sony and its 1st party studios?  I mean honestly I don't understand why you are so committed to Sony Defence its not like your on their payroll.

Uncharted 3 will look beautfiul in 3D and will probably be the most impressive looking console game released so far, yes that is indeed a fact.

But its also a FACT that it is nowhere near what the PC can do in terms of 3D rendering and graphics.  The PS3 just simply isn't anywhere near powerful enough.



Bring it on,  I need more games to justify my purchase of a 3D TV,  as of now I have more Games that support 3D than I do movies.  And personally I think 3D for games is one of the best features implemented for this gen.



BenVTrigger said:

Are you serious right now?  I mean do you honestly buy into every single line of marketing that comes out of Sony and its 1st party studios?  I mean honestly I don't understand why you are so committed to Sony Defence its not like your on their payroll.

Uncharted 3 will look beautfiul in 3D and will probably be the most impressive looking console game released so far, yes that is indeed a fact.

But its also a FACT that it is nowhere near what the PC can do in terms of 3D rendering and graphics.  The PS3 just simply isn't anywhere near powerful enough.

What Naughty Dog did for you doubt them? Why should I doubt the words of Naughty Dog? Because someone here says it is marketing? No. That's my point.

Until you prove them wrong... that's not marketing or I defending the Sony side of the force.

I believe Uncharted 3 will have the best 3D seen in a game IMO.



Around the Network
ethomaz said:
BenVTrigger said:

Are you serious right now?  I mean do you honestly buy into every single line of marketing that comes out of Sony and its 1st party studios?  I mean honestly I don't understand why you are so committed to Sony Defence its not like your on their payroll.

Uncharted 3 will look beautfiul in 3D and will probably be the most impressive looking console game released so far, yes that is indeed a fact.

But its also a FACT that it is nowhere near what the PC can do in terms of 3D rendering and graphics.  The PS3 just simply isn't anywhere near powerful enough.

What Naughty Dog did for you doubt them? That's my point.

Until you prove them wrong... that's not marketing or I defending the Sony side of the force.



The PS3 hardware is not capable of producing full 1080p in each eye running at a constant 60fps with high level graphics.

There I just proved them wrong.



BenVTrigger said:
ethomaz said:
BenVTrigger said:

Are you serious right now?  I mean do you honestly buy into every single line of marketing that comes out of Sony and its 1st party studios?  I mean honestly I don't understand why you are so committed to Sony Defence its not like your on their payroll.

Uncharted 3 will look beautfiul in 3D and will probably be the most impressive looking console game released so far, yes that is indeed a fact.

But its also a FACT that it is nowhere near what the PC can do in terms of 3D rendering and graphics.  The PS3 just simply isn't anywhere near powerful enough.

What Naughty Dog did for you doubt them? That's my point.

Until you prove them wrong... that's not marketing or I defending the Sony side of the force.



The PS3 hardware is not capable of producing full 1080p in each eye running at a constant 60fps with high level graphics.

There I just proved them wrong.

That's not a requirement for 3D.



BenVTrigger said:
ethomaz said:
BenVTrigger said:

Are you serious right now?  I mean do you honestly buy into every single line of marketing that comes out of Sony and its 1st party studios?  I mean honestly I don't understand why you are so committed to Sony Defence its not like your on their payroll.

Uncharted 3 will look beautfiul in 3D and will probably be the most impressive looking console game released so far, yes that is indeed a fact.

But its also a FACT that it is nowhere near what the PC can do in terms of 3D rendering and graphics.  The PS3 just simply isn't anywhere near powerful enough.

What Naughty Dog did for you doubt them? That's my point.

Until you prove them wrong... that's not marketing or I defending the Sony side of the force.



The PS3 hardware is not capable of producing full 1080p in each eye running at a constant 60fps with high level graphics.

There I just proved them wrong.

Naughty Dog didn't even claim that...

You didn't prove anybody wrong, stop putting words in other people's mouths.



Yeah, Uncharted is going to be awesome... wait wth this is a MS discussion I would have never figured that out 



Sig thanks to Saber! :D 

dsister said:

Yeah, Uncharted is going to be awesome... wait wth this is a MS discussion I would have never figured that out 

Oh, I thought this was the "Pachter loves Uncharted 3 in 3D thread" xD.