OK, my thoughts...

Notstan...I don't know what to think of him. He seems convinced that both stefl and theprof cannot be mafia in this game based on their alignment on previous games, and that seems really bad reasoning imo, as the mod probably picked our alignments randomly. As its day 1, we have little to go on... So either he is pro-town, trying to deduce people's alignments early on to try and narrow down some possible scum OR he was trying to manipulate the town into agreeing with him.

But what struck me the most so far was this post -

Does this mean that Silver-Tiger may have a role that is considered to be "evil" in GTA IV ? Would he have said so if he had a role that was considered to be good ? Yeah, you play as a goon in the first place, but there is some good in Niko. Unlike people like, say Dimitri Rascolov, who were just pure fucking evil.

Vote : Silver-Tiger

Explain yourself dude :P

What quote are you talking about ?

now how much of GTA4 have you played exactly?

just to decypher you ^^

but in any case, name =/= alignment as the op says and as is evident by the game setting (all thugs)

about 20 mins of the singleplayer and an hour or so of multiplayer at a LAN once

I think he talks about you quoting silver-tiger.

Unvote

Vote: Zarx

A little less joking, a little more participation, please.

I actually find this more puzzling than informative then ^^.

Participate in what? It's day one and more than half of the players haven't even posted yet. At this point I am just observing you got to remember this is only the seccond Mafia game I have played on VGChartz so I am not familiar with this group of players like you are so I have to learn how everyone plays on the fly before I can start making judgements.

For example I could take your early "aggression" for lack of a better term, as a sign that you are mafia and trying to hard to point suspicion  at other people, or that could just be how you play the game IDK yet...

but for the time being

FOS Stefl1504

In serious conversation, I know there aren't all of the people here yet, but that is no reason for us to just stand still and wait, also I am fine with you joking around, but you could also give us your opinion on some things that already transpired, I like it much more if you are suspicious of me, than when you joke around about bringing girls in here and stealing kidneys (jk ;P)

also I wanted to hear some of your thoughts, so thank you!

I think my vote has found a warm and cosy place for the time being.

So trying to prevoke me into trying to defend myself eh?

Like I said I don't think I really have enough data to make any meaningful analysis at this point but if you want my analysis I would say everyone other than you is going through the usual first day mechinations of blind accusations and inefectual proabing, the only one that is doing anything dodgy is you like I said. You seem very eager to start pointing fingers at people, but again that could be just how you play. 

I guess that does mean I should start trying to find out if you are scum since you are the most suspicious person so far...

So why are you so eager to point fingers at people first day?