man when you guys write navi, my head's first response was

shit I defintely want to hold one of those things in my left hand and squeeze it as it yells "hey! listen! I'm dying!"

That's how Grand Slam Tennis on Wii is played, nunchuck in one hand to move your player around and wii-mote motion plus in the other hand.

Ok. Was just a little bit shocked at the possibility of a game not playing like that since that's how I thought Wii Tennis played before picking it up way back in '07.

That's exactly the point. My first reaction on seeing the thread was that this is in no way a fare comparison. In fact, you can't compare the two devices head2head with the same games. Rather, the respective libraries supporting each device and the immersiveness and fun added by each device should be compared.

I'd argue that tennis is as hardcore as FiFa or Madden or NHL games, it just has a smaller audiance.

If you don't find these hardcore then no complaits here.

Also for tennis you have to consider that Kinnect will have a hard time detecting a slice from a through shot from a spin.... (haven't tried it but it sure needs to be inventive), move just needs a button press (or racket angle detection as you do hold something).

Duplicate: http://gamrconnect.vgchartz.com/thread.php?id=128092 

And really, Sixthaxis, could you find a les biased site? I know Eurogamer liked the move version better